All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

AbsolutVT03
Joined: 01/05/2001
Posts: 36,169
Likes: 25,823
Lifetime

What is Chesney's record? Never mind that I think the vs Top 5 or whatever

stat is overblown and misleading. If you're playing a true top 5 team then you should lose most of the time. This is especially true if you are not a top 5 team. There's also the caveat of how you count Top X teams. Is it their ranking at the time of the game? End of the season? Are you using a specific poll or ranking or any of them or all of them? What if you beat a Top 5 team in game one but that team turns out to be vastly overrated? Conversely if you beat a team early that is underrated and they end up in the Top 10 that win doesn't count towards the stat but it probably should. The point there is you can massage the numbers to make a Top X stat look better or worse than it really is depending on the point you're trying to make. As far as VT and the new coach, whoever we end up with is going to have some flaws or cons or reasons he could fail here. It's kind of a crap shoot really. Even if we went out and poached a current, successful, proven coach from the SEC or Big 10 there's no guarantee it would work. Lincoln Riley and Brian Kelly are two examples of that (Kelly more so right now obviously). At this point I'm ready to support whoever we hire and let them get to work.
Posted: 10/29/2025 at 10:26 AM ET
(In response to this post by mlewisr)

Thread Replies (38)

Full Thread →
Franklin can’t win big games at PSU. Would VT be different?
JHHOKIE 10/29/25 12:05 AM ET
Let’s start with being relevant again.**
97Hokie 10/29/25 09:28 PM ET
Third times the charm?**
VTKATT 10/29/25 03:18 PM ET
We cant get to big games so he should be good!**
DLDesk 10/29/25 11:46 AM ET
We can't win enough to get into a 'big game'...**
banishedtothelounge 10/29/25 11:39 AM ET
Doubtful. Didn't win them at Vandy either. Certainly not worth the risk.**
marcbvtgm 10/29/25 11:19 AM ET
He didn’t have “My sweet boy, Diego”**
VT ChemE 1986 10/29/25 11:29 AM ET
He had a QB who hung around the NFL for 2-3 seasons. And a pretty good RB.
marcbvtgm 10/29/25 06:01 PM ET
VT winning 10+ games a year, but never against top-5, was VT's golden age**
Synaesthesia 10/29/25 10:39 AM ET
What coach is available that has consistently beat top 10 teams? Good luck**
DDhokie31 10/29/25 10:24 AM ET
With top 10 resources? Probably some. But definitely not Franklin.**
marcbvtgm 10/29/25 11:20 AM ET
Saban**
Happy Dog 10/29/25 10:43 AM ET
Key word is "available". No chance in hell he comes to VT**
DDhokie31 10/29/25 08:55 PM ET
He's available if Miss Terry says he is! Lot of $$$ out there.....**
Happy Dog 10/30/25 04:52 AM ET
No idea... but right now we're not even winning little games. If we get to
AbsolutVT03 10/29/25 10:15 AM ET
Couldn't win the big one vs Never been to the big one. Thats the choice
Techsupport 10/29/25 09:25 AM ET
Are we waiting for coach to show up in a chariot and sweep us off our feet?**
bigbadbird 10/29/25 08:29 AM ET
Calling Ben Hur. 😊**
1MetroHokie 10/29/25 09:58 AM ET
Easier to win big ACC games than in the B1G
hburghokie09 10/29/25 08:12 AM ET
VT first has to win game
1947Sunbowl 10/29/25 08:09 AM ET
I do not trust any coach who has had success with the resources of PSU
VT ChemE 1986 10/29/25 11:34 AM ET
At this point, it would be nice for VT to play in some big games.**
reestuart 10/29/25 07:58 AM ET
Lol, what i would give to have big meaningful games to lose again at VT**
Vippie1 10/29/25 07:45 AM ET
You got that right Chesney would be a better choice
mlewisr 10/29/25 07:43 AM ET
What is Chesney's record? Never mind that I think the vs Top 5 or whatever
AbsolutVT03 10/29/25 10:26 AM ET
Good points
mlewisr 10/29/25 10:59 AM ET
James Franklin may be in a better position to defer
Marooned 10/29/25 12:30 PM ET
So he's "basically" tracking with Frank Beamer.**
Techsupport 10/29/25 09:30 AM ET
Agree with you on that - Chesney is on the rise, and we should rise as well**
Happy Dog 10/29/25 09:22 AM ET
He has a bunch of Top-10 finishes (maybe 5?) in his decade at PSU which
Tuckahokie 10/29/25 06:13 AM ET
Except Franklin underachieved given his resources & talent. FB overachieved**
marcbvtgm 10/29/25 11:22 AM ET
Right now we can't win big OR little games, so........**
Happy Dog 10/29/25 06:10 AM ET
He's not my first choice but we could do a lot worse **
HokiesACC2004 10/29/25 05:37 AM ET
We could do worse...that's the attitude for success right there**
marcbvtgm 10/29/25 11:23 AM ET
Whose your Choice ? Just wondering..**
JRHokie 10/29/25 05:38 AM ET
I would roll the dice with Bob Chesney **
HokiesACC2004 10/29/25 05:43 AM ET
With you on that - Franklin is the safe choice, Chesney is out-of-the-box
Happy Dog 10/29/25 06:10 AM ET
JMU has been getting uppity lately...that would be humorous at least :>)**
Tuckahokie 10/29/25 05:54 AM ET
They've earned it - they are playing good football
Happy Dog 10/29/25 10:46 AM ET