A question for GC and Rev. IF the NCAA grants a 5th year as is under
discussion, will that be for 2026 currently ineligible players?
That question being asked, if it is approved, doesn't that make for interesting new portal recruiting, expecially for schools like VT?
TIA!!
3 Replies
3mo
grandfathered in and it takes effect very soon as in this current portal landscape, this would very much change the market. These are big ifs and don’t know where this ultimately ends up as the NCAA has an extremely poor recent record in state, federal and the Supreme Courts. But essentially you will be adding an entire class of seniors into the portal immediately, thus suppressing value as there will be much more supply. A long way from seeing this but it would be an instant and dramatic change to the portal. And if it was decided to grandfather players in for the 5th year you would have to allow them to instantly become portal-eligible due to the change occurring after the portal entry deadline. It could be a fascinating disruption. Possibly beneficial for Virginia Tech and I wonder if we don’t see some programs start really slow playing some things as far as new signings while they try to get clarification. Timing of this is ridiculous but so on point for the NCAA. Who knows how, when and if this even transpires.
** Edited by Rev.Zeke Vodka at 4/23/2026, 4:54:32 PM
(In response to this post by ancient alien 2018)
3mo
answering my question. In other words, I guessed and in reality had no clue! Thanks
(In response to this post by Rev.Zeke Vodka)
3mo
They haven't said one way or the other and lots of people are speculating on the issue
What I would say is...it doesn't matter
Whatever rule they come up with is going to be challenged in court, and the number of NCAA wins in court is in the single digits percentage-wise.
The Executive Order was basically disregarded because it wouldn't hold up, and this is essentially an extension of that.
If they move to a 5 in 5 model and they DONT grandfather in the current players who would be out of eligibility then theyre opening themselves to many lawsuits in every state. That means whether you get a waiver could boil down to the state you filed in or the judge you got.
I think they'll probably push it through, I just dont think it'll wind up solving any issues and create many more issues
(In response to this post by ancient alien 2018)