All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

2
Joined: 10/07/1999
Posts: 37,351
Likes: 54,742
Founder Subscriber

I am aware of the comments.....

you reference and the only addendum would be he has used the "close" wording on more than one occasion. Young has very little to gain, if anything, from the exactness of is timeline and fans, at least most, probably understand this. Fans, at least some, will lose respect and eventually doubt the credibility of his words if he says the same thing with no changes evident. Your last paragraph is the typical condescending tone you are becoming known for more and more. People realize it is not an exact science, they realize there are various thresholds to clear and there are substantial differences between being cleared for physical activity and further rehab versus being competition ready. However, words have meaning and without more specificity it is very easy for fans to feel mislead with a vague term like "close", especially without further context and clarification. To circle back to your earlier question, CMY walks a fine line with his disclosures in terms of trust from fans and we both know that when trust is loss it is very difficult to regain.
Posted: 02/17/2026 at 07:55 PM ET
(In response to this post by GCHokie34)

Thread Replies (35)

Full Thread →
Tyler Johnson…at this point I’ve gotta wonder
hokiepro 02/17/26 06:20 AM ET
Does anyone know what the injury was/is?**
KiloZulu 02/17/26 03:35 PM ET
Broken tibia**
SC_Hokie 02/17/26 03:40 PM ET
Sounds like a season ending type of injury
Zanderhokie 02/17/26 04:07 PM ET
I said he would not play again but was called a liar. 🤷‍♂️**
SC_Hokie 02/17/26 01:23 PM ET
You said he was redshirting...
GCHokie34 02/17/26 02:24 PM ET
No ya said he'd medical redshirt but were shown not mathematically possible
HokieRat 02/17/26 01:37 PM ET
Been wondering same.**
B Hokie 02/17/26 01:18 PM ET
He could have had a broken femur by now and be back playing
sacramento hokie 02/17/26 12:54 PM ET
Ben Boggs broke his femur and was never the same
GCHokie34 02/17/26 01:12 PM ET
Oh they definitely treat them but I felt we were strung along as far
sacramento hokie 02/17/26 04:31 PM ET
Who strung you along?**
GCHokie34 02/17/26 05:17 PM ET
I get playing it close to the.....
2hhoop3 02/17/26 05:40 PM ET
I'm not aware of MY saying anything other than he's close...
GCHokie34 02/17/26 05:58 PM ET
I am aware of the comments.....
2hhoop3 02/17/26 07:55 PM ET
If the semantics of "close" erodes your trust...
GCHokie34 02/17/26 08:27 PM ET
I blame the refs.**
NokieHokie 02/17/26 10:06 AM ET
And Joey brackets!**
Lakeridgehokie 02/17/26 11:50 AM ET
And Blacksburg.**
GoldCoast 02/17/26 02:51 PM ET
What would tampering do?
GCHokie34 02/17/26 09:42 AM ET
Haven’t you figured out yet
Moseley Hokie 02/17/26 07:10 PM ET
Working your way back could include spot duty and min restrictions
hokiepro 02/17/26 10:43 AM ET
He isn't eligible for medical hardship
GCHokie34 02/17/26 10:51 AM ET
how long has it been since Hokiepro was a team manager at W&M?**
HOKIE75-79 02/17/26 12:28 PM ET
Who/when gave a "green light"? if he was cleared to return to practice
6thStreetHokie 02/17/26 08:31 AM ET
Doesn’t explain why MY said he was going to play in game 2 weeks ago
uber hokie 02/17/26 08:34 PM ET
CMY “he’s got the green light” 5 days ago on TTL
hokiepro 02/17/26 10:52 AM ET
Maybe there is a misunderstanding of what "green light" means.
TheFacts 02/17/26 11:28 AM ET
Enjoying the ride is harder in this college sports environment **
hokiepro 02/17/26 12:11 PM ET
Its really tough to enjoy games when I dont know what injuries are
GCHokie34 02/17/26 06:00 PM ET
It’s really tough to enjoy this board with a smart-A
hokiepro 02/17/26 06:13 PM ET
Since when have you ever cared about making the board enjoyable considering
NokieHokie 02/17/26 09:16 PM ET
You can wonder about things without publicly posting your theory
GCHokie34 02/17/26 06:25 PM ET
Pro - its early man - let the meds do their thing, then post...**
U2Hokie 02/17/26 07:35 AM ET
I mean I’m sorry to think that way but it’s where we are in college sports
hokiepro 02/17/26 08:25 AM ET
Im sorry to - it was just an easy laugh...have a great day!**
U2Hokie 02/17/26 08:39 AM ET