All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

G
Joined: 06/11/2002
Posts: 13,309
Likes: 47,080
Lifetime

UVAs recruiting hasn't changed, even after winning a national championship

Maryland went to the Sweet 16 last year, hired a coach many on this board idolizes and now theyre the worst power conference team in the nation There just aren't many schools that have changed their stars unless they've done so across decades with the same coach (Gonzaga, and to a lesser extent Villanova) Blacksburg is going to be Blacksburg. You're going to have to overpay players just to get on the same playing field as your peers. Would a splash hire co opt some cache in the short term? Maybe. But across a full recruiting cycle theyre going to win just about as many games as any other VT coach has won. Gonzaga is going to plummet when Few leaves/retires. Villanova already has. UVA isn't going to all of a sudden land McDonald's All-Americans with regularity even after a championship. It just doesn't happen. I said it years ago but VT as a program, regardless of who is HC is a 50% NCAAT program. Leave someone in the seat long enough and they'll make the tournament about 50% of the time and be on the bubble most of the time. That isn't a Mike Young thing, or a Buzz Williams thing or a Seth Greenberg thing. It's a Blacksburg thing. VT did a great job landing James Franklin to use his brand recognition from PSU. He was smart to not target many non-PSU recruits/transfers because he's the sell...not VT
Posted: 02/07/2026 at 08:01 PM ET
(In response to this post by GoldCoast)

Thread Replies (28)

Full Thread →
MY is a great coach, many will miss him when he’s gone.
MsAHokie 02/07/26 06:45 PM ET
Good? Id say other than 3 games in March a few years ago hes been okay**
Steeltown Hokie 02/07/26 11:47 PM ET
what constitute a great coach?**
Windows NT 02/07/26 08:50 PM ET
A HC who gets the most out of the limited puzzle parts he has to work
ancient alien 2018 02/07/26 09:40 PM ET
great coaches have skills that can convey their messages to the players
Windows NT 02/08/26 12:33 PM ET
Seth Greenberg was an average coach who only looked good because we had
VPI63 02/07/26 08:25 PM ET
He's was unquestionably great defensive coach**
hok1eboy 02/08/26 02:33 PM ET
Coach Young is a very good coach
turkeywinghokie 02/07/26 08:03 PM ET
Very good? You clearly have low standards for coaching**
Steeltown Hokie 02/07/26 11:53 PM ET
i wouldn't put him in the very good coach category... good coach, yes
Windows NT 02/07/26 08:54 PM ET
Completely Agree!!
ABSS Hokie 86 02/07/26 08:26 PM ET
With that attitude should we get out of the ACC
RiverVT 02/07/26 07:15 PM ET
CMY is a great guy and represents the university well.
DCL 02/07/26 07:06 PM ET
Coaching is missing **
untuchVT 02/07/26 10:14 PM ET
Yeah wins. Good enough roster but just not getting it done well enough. **
GoldCoast 02/07/26 07:48 PM ET
I get the sentiment - but this isn’t the same program
GoldCoast 02/07/26 07:05 PM ET
???????????**
ancient alien 2018 02/07/26 08:23 PM ET
?????**
GoldCoast 02/07/26 08:56 PM ET
UVAs recruiting hasn't changed, even after winning a national championship
GCHokie34 02/07/26 08:01 PM ET
I, for the one, am sick and tired of you…
VPI63 02/07/26 11:20 PM ET
Couldn’t have said it better myself
cbhokie1 02/08/26 07:49 PM ET
that was a ricky 'the dragon' steamboat body slam**
Windows NT 02/08/26 12:24 PM ET
Surprised you were able to read my post with your head so far in the sand**
GCHokie34 02/08/26 10:34 AM ET
HAAAaaarrrruuuummmmpppPHHHH!!!!**
U2Hokie 02/08/26 07:31 AM ET
I’d happily take “VT is a 50% NCAAT program.” But that’s not what we’re
GoldCoast 02/07/26 08:51 PM ET
If VT gets in this year it'll be 3 in 7 years...
GCHokie34 02/07/26 09:51 PM ET
A question: If VT provided the team, and were able to offer the same level
ancient alien 2018 02/07/26 08:34 PM ET
What’s wrong with the talent we have now? **
GoldCoast 02/07/26 09:06 PM ET
7 or 8? nothing. Here's an example: Clempsun has played 11 payers tonight
ancient alien 2018 02/07/26 09:12 PM ET