I
Joined:
05/23/2003
Posts:
3,882
Likes:
834
Well I think VT's retention rate appears to be improving, subject to change
always. But our first three recruiting classes under CMY netted 9 recruits of which only 3 are still on the roster. Cattoor will be the first VT player under CMY to stay his entire career. Maddox and Pedulla have the chance to be 2, 3 on that list, subject to change always.
I'd argue that a 33% retention rate is not conducive to an overall winning program in the long run. I think you get that up to 50-60% and then it becomes a realistic strategy to build a roster from your own recruits first and then supplement with transfers. I believe CMY's system relies on developing/building up players, so I don't think he could employ an only transfers strategy and be effective. I do think that when he has a really good roster, spending capital on the Darren Buchanan's of the world is foolish. VT could have used a 6th guard this year and it could have been the difference between making the tournament and not.
But I think if you look at K State, there's a really argument that their strategy is the better one. I don't know the players on their team outside of N'Guessan, but obviously we developed him into the player he is now - K State didn't have to take the early career lumps, they got the finished product. An obviously, he wanted to leave to go to K State - so it was a mutually beneficial decision for both. That said, it may just be they hit on a higher number of transfers than you can reasonably expect a team to do on a yearly basis. They've jump started their program though with an Elite 8. And you can't get to the Elite 8 if you don't make the tournament to begin with.
Thread Replies (11)
Bill Roth made an interesting point on twitter Re: KSU
-- hoosnowahokie
Mar 24, 2023 at 06:54 AM ET
hoosnowahokie
•
03/24/23 06:54 AM ET
So IMO this is a preferable model than KY Duke etc
-- Vippie1
Mar 24, 2023 at 10:28 AM ET
Vippie1
•
03/24/23 10:28 AM ET
Only a matter of time before UK, Duke, et al figure out how to balance it**
-- marcbvtgm
Mar 24, 2023 at 12:42 PM ET
marcbvtgm
•
03/24/23 12:42 PM ET
NIL and the portal have greatly increased parity
-- hoosnowahokie
Mar 24, 2023 at 11:31 AM ET
hoosnowahokie
•
03/24/23 11:31 AM ET
There are 2 holdovers including last night’s MVP**
-- Lancelot Link
Mar 24, 2023 at 09:43 AM ET
Lancelot Link
•
03/24/23 09:43 AM ET
Right but neither signed w/KSU out of HS**
-- hokiepro
Mar 24, 2023 at 11:32 AM ET
hokiepro
•
03/24/23 11:32 AM ET
Yes,but they also were transfers before that**
-- HokieBrazil
Mar 24, 2023 at 10:05 AM ET
HokieBrazil
•
03/24/23 10:05 AM ET
The key point how to define program ?? And price ..
-- Mercury
Mar 24, 2023 at 07:49 AM ET
Mercury
•
03/24/23 07:49 AM ET
That’s my question about Duke and Kentucky
-- Squatro
Mar 24, 2023 at 12:34 PM ET
Squatro
•
03/24/23 12:34 PM ET
Well I think VT's retention rate appears to be improving, subject to change
◄
-- IronBlood
Mar 24, 2023 at 10:16 AM ET
IronBlood
•
03/24/23 10:16 AM ET
The entire team left - what were they supposed to do?**
-- AnotherTechW
Mar 24, 2023 at 08:05 AM ET
AnotherTechW
•
03/24/23 08:05 AM ET