All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

M
Joined: 12/29/2006
Posts: 14,868
Likes: 5,100

Underperforming or Overperforming is a matter of perspective.

IMO, they've underperformed a bit. The parts seem better than the whole. And that usually means the coach(es) didn't get this team to gel in an era when you have to get them ready right away despite new faces. These days that's probably the most important job of a head basketball coach. Making the NCAA tourney is not that big of deal. This year around 33 or 34 P4 schools will probably make the tourney. It's not that difficult. It's only slightly more difficult than making a bowl game in football. Yet many folks here act as if it's some grand achievement. It shouldn't be the goal; it should be the expectation. Yet Mike Young has only likely going to make it twice in 7 seasons - and one of those was only because they team got hot late. I like Mike Young and think he can coach the "game", but I think the "sport" has passed him by to some extent - and it's getting further in the rear view mirror each year. I don't really see that changing appreciably - more $$ or not. In fact, I think it only gets more frustrating for him and fans. ** Edited by marcbvtgm at 3/1/2026, 6:30:12 PM ** Edited by marcbvtgm at 3/2/2026, 8:53:55 AM
Posted: 03/01/2026 at 06:18 PM ET
(In response to this post by Vippie1)

Thread Replies (10)

Full Thread →
IMO this team has neither underperformed or overperformed
Vippie1 03/01/26 11:00 AM ET
Still think we would have about 4 more wins if we had "average"...
EDGEMAN 03/02/26 06:22 AM ET
not having Johnson for basically the entire conference schedule was killer
ShockWaveVT 03/03/26 09:35 AM ET
We performed exactly as predicted. ACC preseason media poll ranked us #12
Zanderhokie 03/01/26 09:21 PM ET
Underperforming or Overperforming is a matter of perspective.
marcbvtgm 03/01/26 06:18 PM ET
Last year shouldn't be compared to anything, beyond why we need a new AD..
GoldCoast 03/01/26 01:25 PM ET
You never will, he is what he is
lazarus1 03/01/26 04:01 PM ET
For me the Noe Hype, and having Hansberry had my expectations to high**
George Baylor 03/01/26 11:41 AM ET
I dont think you were wrong
Vippie1 03/01/26 11:49 AM ET
I agree with most of this. I wouldn't dismiss the injuries quite as easily
HokieEngineer 03/01/26 11:27 AM ET
very fair.**
GoldCoast 03/01/26 03:24 PM ET