All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

David Cunningham
Joined: 07/02/2021
Posts: 8,013
Likes: 25,011
Lifetime

I don't think there's anything wrong with Caldwell. And I think

she'll be a very good coach at the D-I level for a long time to come. But she lacks experience at this level. The difference between her and Duffy is that Duffy is a proven winner at the P6 level. Caldwell's only spent one season in D-I period. Give her a few years and she'll really start to catch some interest though.
Posted: 04/03/2024 at 06:13 PM ET
(In response to this post by jonnyhawk)

Thread Replies (36)

Full Thread →
My personal opinion on the Whit Hire..........
jonnyhawk 04/03/24 04:54 PM ET
It’s beyond time for Hokies to stop wanting local only hires. **
Brewing_Hokie 04/03/24 06:51 PM ET
I might agree but the landscape and our budgets say otherwise.**
jonnyhawk 04/03/24 07:00 PM ET
Our budgets say to hire the best candidate that fits without only focusing
Brewing_Hokie 04/03/24 07:16 PM ET
I don't think there's anything wrong with Caldwell. And I think
David CunninghamAdmin 04/03/24 06:13 PM ET
Your reasoning is sound, and I think would make sense with an SEC budget.
jonnyhawk 04/03/24 06:17 PM ET
When Duffy leaves, maybe it will be time for your obsession.**
NokieHokie 04/03/24 06:42 PM ET
I trust Whit **
HokiesACC2004 04/03/24 05:59 PM ET
Whit hired Fuente, Buzz, and thought Kenny was staying. Whoops.
jonnyhawk 04/03/24 06:09 PM ET
Those were 3 very good hires.**
NokieHokie 04/03/24 06:43 PM ET
We don’t need a “Mulkey Junior” in Blacksburg.**
SLH76 04/03/24 05:58 PM ET
I have forgotten your post already…**
hokiesteve01 04/03/24 05:51 PM ET
Caldwell only has 1 yr experience at the D1 level. IMO, our new coach has
Hokie`79 04/03/24 05:39 PM ET
You like Caldwell because she is easy on the eyes:). I agree!**
VTBAMA 04/03/24 05:30 PM ET
She runs the Grinnell System
North Main Hokie 04/03/24 05:24 PM ET
Brooks was VA born, bred and educated. How’d that go?**
Va AandM 04/03/24 05:20 PM ET
Pretty damn good but it's no reason to hire Caldwell.**
MidloHokie 04/03/24 05:40 PM ET
Agree. Not the defining attribute **
Va AandM 04/03/24 06:15 PM ET
I compare Caldwell to Paul Johnston from GT,she is stuck to a system and
HokieBrazil 04/03/24 05:00 PM ET
In fairness sometimes you play what ya got. Give her a Kitley and she would
DGHOKIE 04/03/24 05:54 PM ET
Very true. Good coaches find best way to win with the talent they have.**
Hokie98 04/03/24 06:24 PM ET
Exactly. That approach makes a lot of sense at a place where you can't . .
MidloHokie 04/03/24 05:42 PM ET
If no one is offering then your coach is not accomplishing much**
tallahasseehokie 04/03/24 04:58 PM ET
Something is wrong with you or just ignorant. Caldwell is no
VTMONEY94 04/03/24 04:56 PM ET
Hope you are proven right. My guess, Duffy gone after 2 seasons.**
jonnyhawk 04/03/24 04:58 PM ET
Means she did a damn good job here **
HokiesACC2004 04/03/24 06:00 PM ET
So, you're not going hire someone because they might be . . .
MidloHokie 04/03/24 05:44 PM ET
If she is, it means she was wildly successful
VT Pops 04/03/24 05:29 PM ET
And hopefully by then
crazylane 04/03/24 05:46 PM ET
Is she is gone that means we win
texashokie1 04/03/24 05:25 PM ET
johnny, you’re a funny guy. **
Stork 04/03/24 05:20 PM ET
Not the adjective I had in mind.
74hokie 04/03/24 05:34 PM ET
Perhaps you were looking for "highly intelligent", "insightful","superior"
jonnyhawk 04/03/24 05:38 PM ET
NOW you have the humor. **
74hokie 04/03/24 07:33 PM ET
Not really **
DGHOKIE 04/03/24 05:23 PM ET
I'll put money on at least three**
`lag 04/03/24 05:12 PM ET
I think she stays unless Notre Dame or the right SEC or BIG 10
Hokie_Forester 04/03/24 05:02 PM ET