All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

VAHokie89
Joined: 03/07/2002
Posts: 79,005
Likes: 22,767

I don't think the article goes far enough

When it says that coaches have two jobs: develop and win games, and winning games takes priority....I would hazard that many players who are encouraged to transfer would easily help their previous team win games. And where there is an focus on new coaches, this happens with existing coaches and it isnt just about someone being over-recruited. We KNOW there are players who can help the teams win, who are quite capable of starting and contributing, etc but are encouraged to transer, many going to another D1 school, starting, and doing well or even better. Sometimes it is also about coaches latching on to favorites. I know the "coaches see them every day" mindset but we also know coaches get fired for reasons, some of them being bad personnel decisions. I think the article had the potential to do be so much more. It does not even go in depth on the dark side of the transfer portal.
Posted: 09/07/2025 at 03:05 PM ET
(In response to this post by VTChip)

Thread Replies (8)

Full Thread →
@VTChip , got this softball SI article on my news feed
saret 09/06/25 10:24 AM ET
I don't think the portal has that dark side. Players can get up and leave
IB4TECH 09/08/25 08:27 PM ET
It does have a dark side, I can confirm. Not saying things didn't end up
rberry7676 09/09/25 12:11 AM ET
Didn't realize your daughter transferred again!
VT_AD 09/09/25 02:07 PM ET
Thank you! I really appreciate that.**
rberry7676 09/10/25 03:22 PM ET
Thanks. That's a pretty fair article
VTChip 09/06/25 01:05 PM ET
I don't think the article goes far enough
VAHokie89 09/07/25 03:05 PM ET
182 in the portal - 48 found new homes. 26% success, 74% no success.
laphroaig 09/06/25 07:29 PM ET
Or went D3**
UpperQuad 09/07/25 11:57 AM ET