All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

VTChip
Joined: 11/07/1999
Posts: 40,843
Likes: 145,955
Founder Lifetime

NCAA tweaks proposed 5-for-5 rule; vote schedule for June 23-24

The NCAA Cabinet met Friday and tweaked the proposed 5-for-5 Rule. The key point of this age-based eligibility model would allow student-athletes up to five years of competition during a five-year window. The idea is to simplify eligibility and eliminate all the current exceptions, such as redshirt seasons, medical waivers, and subjective hardship appeals. Yesterday’s tweak, per ESPN, “now says the clock will start upon initial full-time enrollment in college or at the beginning of the academic year following their 19th birthday, whichever occurs first.” The rule has a lot of support, including NCAA President Charlie Baker and outgoing VT President Tim Sands, who is currently the Chairman of the Division I Board of Directors. Sands was quoted as saying “This is about clear and consistent standards. The time is now to reform the period of eligibility rules.” This rule will reportedly take effect at the beginning of the 2026–27 academic year, which means current student-athletes would be covered and could potentially play a fifth season. So VT softball’s upcoming year’s roster, including seniors-to-be Michelle Chatfield, Emma Mazzarone, Zoe Yaeger, Addy Foster, Annika Rohs and others, could play an extra year, IF they so desired (AND IF there were a roster spot available). The downside, as Extra Inning Softball recently pointed out, is the roster congestion that this rule could cause. For example, VT Softball currently has five commits in the Class of 2027. If the roster limit stays at 25 (which it sounds like it will), there could be a real log jam if some of the players want to play a fifth year. Stay tuned.
Posted: 06/06/2026 at 06:29 PM ET

Thread Replies (16)

Full Thread →
NCAA tweaks proposed 5-for-5 rule; vote schedule for June 23-24
VTChip 06/06/26 06:29 PM ET
If it passes, they should increase the roster limits
UpperQuad 06/07/26 02:12 PM ET
Depends on what develops. Junior Colleges, Community Colleges could start
laphroaig 06/07/26 03:50 PM ET
This will penalize athletes and other schools who do missions.
UpperQuad 06/07/26 01:27 PM ET
IMO, there will be not negative repercussions for ...
Atlee Hokie 06/07/26 03:08 PM ET
Those are actually allowable exceptions
VTChip 06/07/26 02:08 PM ET
How many scholarships did softball end up with?**
FriendofCoal 06/07/26 07:08 AM ET
25 is the NCAA limit**
VTChip 06/07/26 10:53 AM ET
I should of said how many are we funding?**
FriendofCoal 06/07/26 11:08 AM ET
I do not know that
VTChip 06/07/26 12:12 PM ET
Based on what was said by the volleyball and men's tennis coach at the . .
MidloHokie 06/07/26 05:04 PM ET
I think 5 years with the gap in scholarships will lead to a
FriendofCoal 06/07/26 05:21 PM ET
Didn't COVID create a similar log jam for high school recruits?**
nkhooch 06/07/26 04:26 AM ET
Somewhat, but the NCAA allowed roster exemptions
VTChip 06/07/26 12:16 PM ET
If this passes it messes with that last several years of recruiting.
laphroaig 06/07/26 01:58 PM ET
Getting a 5th year for that bunch would be awesome!
Hockeydad 06/06/26 09:18 PM ET
One recruited senior last season vs six next season. Have to do some
laphroaig 06/07/26 06:48 AM ET