All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

`lag
Joined: 12/13/1999
Posts: 81,634
Likes: 27,383
Founder Subscriber

coulda shoulda been on the Olympic team... just that they had their three

name recognition, playing time and all that and I get it, that's the way things work out sometimes, late to the gate and no doubt those three were deserving too... ...so she no-hit the USA Olympic team as a little reminder. Tincher >> Olympic team >> rest of world. Too bad about Grein, I saw her progress, even mentioned it to Pete when I ran into him at Cabo Fish Taco one afternoon. (not that he probably didn't know that already, just that I wanted to say something clever) It's a shame Carrie Eberle went off to Okie State, I truly believe if she had stayed one more year she could have held off UCLA in the second game, win it, or let Keely come back strong/disrupt their groove of seeing her for three games straight. Having said that, all power to Carrie for getting the education she wanted, criminal justice or something like that which I guess VT doesn't have. That's what it is all about...but, we always seem to lose that one person who put us over the top. ** Edited by `lag at 2/27/2025, 5:57:44 PM
Posted: 02/27/2025 at 05:36 PM ET
(In response to this post by McHokie93)

Thread Replies (21)

Full Thread →
Who is better: Lemley, Rochard, or Tincher?
McHokie93 02/27/25 02:53 PM ET
Tincher**
VANESSAHOKIE 02/28/25 11:44 PM ET
Basically Lemley is a good pitcher but the type that you see every few
AbsolutVT03 02/28/25 02:22 PM ET
The Tincher numbers are really insane
hokiepro 02/28/25 01:11 AM ET
Tincher should’ve been on US Olympic team
hokiepro 02/28/25 01:05 AM ET
Tincher, the GOAT pitcher in VT history. And no pitcher even close.
carhokies 02/27/25 07:23 PM ET
This question was asked recently. Tincher by a landslide...
jesuisvtguy 02/27/25 06:05 PM ET
More than that!**
Tech76G 02/27/25 06:18 PM ET
coulda shoulda been on the Olympic team... just that they had their three
`lag 02/27/25 05:36 PM ET
Tincher is #1. If we would of had more of an offense they could have won it
Hokie_Forester 02/27/25 04:47 PM ET
Slight correction... she would be dominant (with a period) ;)**
jesuisvtguy 02/27/25 06:07 PM ET
Read the Record Book, its self explanatory. (Link)**
TheFacts 02/27/25 04:39 PM ET
I would advise you........
2hhoop3 02/27/25 04:32 PM ET
If you asked me to take Tinch or the NCAA field, I'd take Tinch
VT_AD 02/27/25 04:24 PM ET
Not even close. AT is possibly one of the ten best pitchers to ever live.
MidloHokie 02/27/25 03:53 PM ET
Comparing these three
ForgeHokie 02/27/25 03:44 PM ET
Tinch is in a league of her own
92Hokie14 02/27/25 03:42 PM ET
It has to be Tincher
VTChip 02/27/25 03:28 PM ET
Tincher was a generational talent similar to MV1 was in football.
laphroaig 02/27/25 03:35 PM ET
Tincher is on the VT Athletics Mount Rushmore
UpperQuad 02/27/25 04:08 PM ET
Tincher by a landslide!!
VT_AD 02/27/25 03:18 PM ET
Thanks, did not know about her great academics.**
Hotus 02/28/25 12:26 PM ET