Login | Sign Up
TechSideline

All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

Softball Board
◀ ▶
2
Joined: 10/07/1999
Posts: 37,351
Likes: 54,742
2hhoop3
Founder Subscriber

I would advise you........

to look at AT's numbers and compare them to the other 2. No offense intended to either Lemley or Rochard but, both could have likely pitched at VT for 8 years and they might still not pass her stats. Both are really good pitchers but, AT is a generational player, likely in the all time Top 5 and certainly in the Top 10.
Posted: 02/27/2025 at 04:32 PM ET
(In response to this post by McHokie93)

Thread Replies (21)

Full Thread →
Who is better: Lemley, Rochard, or Tincher?
McHokie93 • 02/27/25 02:53 PM ET
Tincher**
VANESSAHOKIE • 02/28/25 11:44 PM ET
Basically Lemley is a good pitcher but the type that you see every few
AbsolutVT03 • 02/28/25 02:22 PM ET
The Tincher numbers are really insane
hokiepro • 02/28/25 01:11 AM ET
Tincher should’ve been on US Olympic team
hokiepro • 02/28/25 01:05 AM ET
Tincher, the GOAT pitcher in VT history. And no pitcher even close.
carhokies • 02/27/25 07:23 PM ET
This question was asked recently. Tincher by a landslide...
jesuisvtguy • 02/27/25 06:05 PM ET
More than that!**
Tech76G • 02/27/25 06:18 PM ET
coulda shoulda been on the Olympic team... just that they had their three
`lag • 02/27/25 05:36 PM ET
Tincher is #1. If we would of had more of an offense they could have won it
Hokie_Forester • 02/27/25 04:47 PM ET
Slight correction... she would be dominant (with a period) ;)**
jesuisvtguy • 02/27/25 06:07 PM ET
Read the Record Book, its self explanatory. (Link)**
TheFacts • 02/27/25 04:39 PM ET
I would advise you........ ◄
2hhoop3 • 02/27/25 04:32 PM ET
If you asked me to take Tinch or the NCAA field, I'd take Tinch
VT_AD • 02/27/25 04:24 PM ET
Not even close. AT is possibly one of the ten best pitchers to ever live.
MidloHokie • 02/27/25 03:53 PM ET
Comparing these three
ForgeHokie • 02/27/25 03:44 PM ET
Tinch is in a league of her own
92Hokie14 • 02/27/25 03:42 PM ET
It has to be Tincher
VTChip • 02/27/25 03:28 PM ET
Tincher was a generational talent similar to MV1 was in football.
laphroaig • 02/27/25 03:35 PM ET
Tincher is on the VT Athletics Mount Rushmore
UpperQuad • 02/27/25 04:08 PM ET
Tincher by a landslide!!
VT_AD • 02/27/25 03:18 PM ET
Thanks, did not know about her great academics.**
Hotus • 02/28/25 12:26 PM ET