All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

VTHokie2000
Joined: 01/01/2005
Posts: 41,416
Likes: 17,028

I believe VT was "penalized" for the 2 point loss in 2001 because VT did

drop 1 or 2 places in the next poll and using revisionist history won't change it. You assume I am using selection bias, but you forget listing every big win and big loss would be a lengthy task and maybe exceed character space (assuming TSL has one for its posts). Also, the WVU game is a conference game which has no impact on the OOC narrative is what people typically use when comparing 2 or more conferences against each other. If you truly believe that ESPN and other third parties are incorrect about their perception of VT football, then by all means prove them wrong. Show VT has won just as many big games as it has lost, VT has just as many impressive big wins as big losses, or whatever other criteria you want to use. Heck it doesn't even matter the starting point for your exercise because there is always the possibility the narrative began for VT before that point. I guess if you truly want to be safe, then you would use 1892 as your starting point because that was the first year VT played football. I don't believe I have anything else worthwhile to add to this conversation. I believe I have shown more than enough examples to respond to Big 12 guy's statement that VT being relatively new to the scene as being the main thing holding the program back. Heck I didn't even talk about how FSU has a similar history as VT given that the program really didn't "arrive" until Bobby Bowden became their HC in 1976. It really wasn't until 1987 season when the program really took off to become what it is perceived today. If you have something to say about the being new to the scene vs. big game record discussion, then I may (or may not) have something worthwhile to add to that discussion. If not, then I hope you enjoy the rest of your day and have a great weekend.
Posted: 04/04/2025 at 09:49 AM ET
(In response to this post by HokieEngineer)

Thread Replies (65)

Full Thread →
Am I the only one that thinks the BIG and the SEC have had a "Yalta"
manassashoo 03/29/25 05:18 PM ET
I would not be surprised if you are right, Sankey & Pettiti I thought said
Stech 03/31/25 01:23 PM ET
If this is true , it would make sense that UVA and UNC
Sunsetunderground 03/31/25 01:15 PM ET
Softball, golf, gymnastics, track and field are all pretty
Pylons 04/01/25 03:03 PM ET
Also, swimming and tennis**
manassashoo 04/02/25 10:23 AM ET
UVa to B1G is the best angle for us to get into the P2 (in this case, SEC).
Maroon Baboon 03/31/25 02:25 PM ET
Careful what you ask for. Do you think things would be all that
Big12 guy 03/31/25 02:42 PM ET
Recruiting and portal would be a whole notha level if NIL could keep up.**
Maroon Unit 03/31/25 10:35 PM ET
I'll take my chances.**
Maroon Baboon 03/31/25 03:25 PM ET
we kinda have nothing to lose right now....
MrBayAreaHokie 04/01/25 11:53 AM ET
SEC is a possibility. BigXII more likely. Staying in a watered down ACC is
Maroon Baboon 04/01/25 02:36 PM ET
I hope my school doesn't take the invite. While I understand that some
Big12 guy 03/31/25 03:32 PM ET
It's also about geography and established conference affiliation.
Maroon Baboon 03/31/25 03:40 PM ET
I think VT's geography hurts them. If the East Coast was
Big12 guy 03/31/25 05:58 PM ET
I was referring to travel, not markets (re: geography) **
Maroon Baboon 03/31/25 07:13 PM ET
I understand, but except for the fans and money, a three
Big12 guy 03/31/25 07:33 PM ET
I have to disagree with your premise that "regional conference is over
VTHokie2000 04/01/25 10:37 PM ET
As a fan not on the East Coast, this neck of the woods never enjoyed
Big12 guy 04/02/25 08:34 AM ET
The answer to that question is it depends (on probably 2 factors).
VTHokie2000 04/02/25 09:16 AM ET
If you look at the miles and travel time of all of those "regional"
Big12 guy 04/02/25 09:30 AM ET
I am not sure that is necessarily true. Particularly if you factor in the
VTHokie2000 04/02/25 10:36 AM ET
I agree with the rivalry aspect 100%. Except for ND/USC, I think most
Big12 guy 04/02/25 10:44 AM ET
Yes, historically that is how the majority of the rivalries formed.
VTHokie2000 04/02/25 11:18 AM ET
IMO, the VT fanbase seems to fit the Big Ten better than SEC. Not that
reestuart 03/31/25 06:12 PM ET
The Big East was a good conference, but frankly, VT would fit in any of
Big12 guy 03/31/25 06:43 PM ET
Yeah, and as far as fanbase fit goes, I'd say that is at about the bottom
reestuart 04/01/25 08:12 AM ET
Even though VT football didn't appear on the scene until the late 90s, I'm
VTHokie2000 03/31/25 09:52 PM ET
While I would like to have a better "big game" record, there are some games
HokieEngineer 04/03/25 10:14 PM ET
The Miami and WVU games you mention are conference games which do help with
VTHokie2000 04/04/25 08:20 AM ET
I would argue that if you're not going to count the conference wins, you
HokieEngineer 04/04/25 09:11 AM ET
I believe VT was "penalized" for the 2 point loss in 2001 because VT did
VTHokie2000 04/04/25 09:49 AM ET
Think they’re headed 2 heavy unequal sharing by individual school like ACC
Stech 03/29/25 06:56 PM ET
Listening to the podcast today, I’ll go you one step further
Marooned 03/31/25 05:10 PM ET
What podcast said that? TIA**
Stech 03/31/25 06:24 PM ET
TSL 416
Marooned 04/01/25 05:54 PM ET
Yes I figured it out, and listened to it, it was great, thanks for letting
Stech 04/01/25 08:15 PM ET
Yep, ACC is currently serving as the guinea pig.
VTCALS72 03/30/25 08:49 AM ET
Yep, they are also watching Oregon State challenging penalties for leaving
Stech 03/30/25 08:57 AM ET
Nobody "waits to see what the ACC does first"....except maybe the CAA**
VTNuke 03/29/25 09:45 PM ET
That is probably correct
VTCALS72 03/30/25 08:51 AM ET
Never underestimate the Blue Blood schools desire for more 💵 and power.**
Stech 03/30/25 09:26 PM ET
Been reported by ESPN insiders the P2 are watching ACC unequal sharing and
Stech 03/30/25 08:24 AM ET
The ACC has done it before, but I think the equal sharing worked the best
HOO86 03/31/25 12:01 AM ET
You sure about that split.........
2hhoop3 03/31/25 08:40 PM ET
Here's an article with referenc to it.**
HOO86 03/31/25 09:11 PM ET
Here is another one.
HOO86 03/31/25 09:13 PM ET
Thanks for the replies.....
2hhoop3 03/31/25 09:54 PM ET
You're Welcome! But fast forward to today
HOO86 03/31/25 10:08 PM ET
Nobody knows.......
2hhoop3 03/31/25 10:20 PM ET
It’s about math/higher number, but it’s also about guaranteed vs variable💵
Stech 04/01/25 08:51 AM ET
The old adage......
2hhoop3 04/01/25 09:08 AM ET
Yep, I keep thinking about Mark Felt (Deep Throat) and “follow the money”.
Stech 04/01/25 09:50 AM ET
I think the MAG 7
MrFantastic! 03/31/25 08:14 AM ET
Probably won't happen soon enough to prevent some schools' athletic
Maroon Baboon 03/31/25 09:32 AM ET
Wow UNC & Duke really got 50% of the ACC revenue & the other 50% was split?
Stech 03/31/25 01:25 AM ET
Football revenue was done by the NCAA
mrcaniac 03/31/25 01:52 PM ET
It was primarily basketball because football was separate
HOO86 03/31/25 11:03 AM ET
Another tidbit.
HOO86 03/31/25 06:33 PM ET
🤣🤣🤣 now that’s funny, I don’t care who you are!!!!**
Stech 03/31/25 08:26 PM ET
Yes. And other programs were no joke either: Maryland and GT for instance.
Maroon Baboon 03/31/25 01:44 AM ET
Duke played in the National Championship Game in the 60s, 70s, and 80s
HOO86 03/31/25 11:16 AM ET
They were very good back then, but so was State & UMd, I would not describe
Stech 03/31/25 11:58 AM ET
True. Coach K started winning championships for Duke
HOO86 03/31/25 09:25 PM ET
That explains it, Raycom favoring those two makes sense.**
Stech 03/31/25 09:54 PM ET
Could be a mistake, The greed will do that to you**
wwhokie1 03/30/25 12:29 PM ET
When it finally comes down to schools, the bovine feces will hit the fan,
ancient alien 2018 03/29/25 06:42 PM ET