Login | Sign Up
TechSideline

All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

Conference Realignment Board
◀ ▶
L
Joined: 01/04/2001
Posts: 22,733
Likes: 6,129
lawhokie

It looks to me that, advancing frame by frame,

The ball is stationary for three frames. You cannot really see how the ball is secured, but that’s not the point. The replay ref has to establish how it is not a catch, not how it is.
Posted: 09/28/2024 at 10:44 AM ET
(In response to this post by manassashoo)

Thread Replies (30)

Full Thread →
INDISPUTABLE VIDEO EVIDENCE, LETS SEE IT ACC!! Commissioner Jim Phillips
Stech • 09/28/24 12:19 AM ET
I can see NOW why its good to have a in your face AD and President
1947Sunbowl • 09/28/24 02:15 PM ET
Definitely wasn't a catch and the holding call was worse**
SpeakToDamien • 09/28/24 10:58 AM ET
None of the video views were indisputable, the ref had a great view, he was
Stech • 09/28/24 11:04 AM ET
interesting picture acc chief of officials making the call
1947Sunbowl • 09/29/24 12:08 PM ET
A. Who cares if he lives in Miami?
Pylons • 09/30/24 03:23 AM ET
WOW if true!!!!**
Stech • 09/29/24 01:41 PM ET
I didn't hear them disputing a catch on what I saw tweeted.
HOO86 • 09/28/24 03:48 PM ET
I saw that, but please show the irrefutable video evidence that it happened
Stech • 09/28/24 04:03 PM ET
IF, a big IF, they actually.........
2hhoop3 • 09/28/24 10:48 PM ET
Bingo, that’s the point, show us how you got there ACC!!**
Stech • 09/28/24 10:51 PM ET
Agreed. I just saw her report that earlier.
HOO86 • 09/28/24 04:45 PM ET
Best video I’ve seen, Miami player trying to pull it out after he’s down.**
Stech • 09/28/24 05:37 PM ET
I don’t understand why the ACC didn’t take the easy way out
HokieAl • 09/29/24 08:57 AM ET
They did say it was still moving by using the word "loose". The issue
dallasvt • 09/29/24 06:42 PM ET
Because it was a catch according to the only person that could see it, ref
Stech • 09/29/24 09:12 AM ET
Here you go**
manassashoo • 09/28/24 09:34 AM ET
Ha, wow...yeah that's not a catch as far as I'm concerned.
MP4VT2004 • 09/28/24 08:46 PM ET
LOL you think you’re smarter than Nick Saban about College Football & ref
Stech • 09/28/24 10:47 PM ET
I can't keep up...are we supposed to like Nick Saban or hate him?
MP4VT2004 • 09/29/24 04:33 PM ET
LOL!**
HwoodHokie • 09/28/24 10:32 PM ET
He’s on his back with the ball, not even close to indisputable, if that’s
Stech • 09/28/24 09:42 AM ET
Here is how the replay officials could wrongly justify overturning call
wwhokie1 • 09/28/24 05:50 PM ET
Exactly, they don’t even talk to the ref on the field, it’s flawed in so
Stech • 09/28/24 09:01 PM ET
Seems to me the ball is in the air and not being possessed. **
manassashoo • 09/28/24 10:12 AM ET
Yeah, “seems” isn’t enough to overturn the ruling of a catch.
hokieZ71 • 09/29/24 08:25 AM ET
In the still photo? That's after his butt hit the ground.**
Pylons • 09/28/24 10:57 AM ET
It looks to me that, advancing frame by frame, ◄
lawhokie • 09/28/24 10:44 AM ET
That video is not indisputable, the ref was right there, he’s the only one
Stech • 09/28/24 10:23 AM ET
Game Day unanimously said it was a terrible call, usually 1 goes w/ refs,
Stech • 09/28/24 10:10 AM ET
I.e., the indisputable video evidence has been vigorously disputed**
lawhokie • 09/28/24 10:46 AM ET