All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

mrcaniac
Joined: 11/27/2012
Posts: 2,011
Likes: 1,244

Nothing wrong with unions

I've been on the other side from them where I worked one time. They represented those employees well. As with anything, there will be some changes if the athletes are able to unionize. It won't be separate unions for each sport, there will be one union representing all the athletes. The athletes will want to set a minimum of compensation/benefits, in exchange for that, the athletic departments will want to set maximum compensation/benefits limits. Thus, all NIL money could be subject to being pooled together so that Olivia Dunn will be making a lot less while the 3rd string kicker will be making more money because as part of the CBA, the athletes' NIL could be owned by the schools. Also, the transfer portal could get shut down, and players could actually be traded to other schools. Bama might need a running back that Kansas has, so they trade a couple of linemen or even a basketball player for him. Let's not forget the scholarships, housing, and meals that the athletes receive now. Those will now need to be paid by somebody, and those somebodies will be the athletes themselves. The NBA, NFL, NHL, MLB, and other leagues don't pay for food, housing, or education except for when the team travels. Also, who will this union be negotiating with? Individual schools? Individual states? Individual conferences? Or the NCAA? Currently, the pro leagues have a union that negotiates their CBA with their league so that each team is bound by the CBA. If their isn't a CBA with "College Sports, Inc", then it will be a hodgepodge of agreements with unequal terms.
Posted: 09/14/2023 at 06:34 PM ET
(In response to this post by Stech)

Thread Replies (25)

Full Thread →
Dartmouth men’s basketball team is seeking to form a union. Here we go.**
Femoyer Hokie 09/14/23 10:11 AM ET
I would love to hear my old
GCHokieof91 09/15/23 04:17 PM ET
Imagine the leverage they have
Vippie1 09/15/23 08:11 AM ET
National Labor Relations suing USC & NCAA 4 not classifying em employees 🔗
Stech 09/14/23 01:42 PM ET
Not a game changer
mrcaniac 09/14/23 11:05 AM ET
Unions are created for better pay & benefits, seems like a game changer
Stech 09/14/23 01:22 PM ET
Reagan...
khakiblue 09/14/23 07:29 PM ET
Not really.
EDGEMAN 09/15/23 05:09 AM ET
There is a marked difference between private sector unions and public
Big12 guy 09/15/23 03:14 PM ET
How effective they are is another conversation, but they’re established to
Stech 09/14/23 09:26 PM ET
And the end of amateur college sports**
83Hokie 09/18/23 05:29 PM ET
Ended a long time ago, when Coaches started making millions of dollars.
Stech 09/18/23 07:46 PM ET
The evolution of unions over the past 70 years?**
WestyHokie 09/14/23 07:27 PM ET
The evolution from student athlete to employee could be the biggest change
Stech 09/14/23 09:31 PM ET
Nothing wrong with unions
mrcaniac 09/14/23 06:34 PM ET
I can see strikes center on football season**
83Hokie 09/18/23 05:32 PM ET
Nothing wrong with the CONCEPT of unions...
jesuisvtguy 09/14/23 10:41 PM ET
You are describing the current arrangement in professional sports. I don't
33laszlo99 09/14/23 08:07 PM ET
It's all negotiable in a CBA
mrcaniac 09/15/23 12:46 AM ET
Many states have laws against public sector unions
mrcaniac 09/14/23 02:35 PM ET
Virginia is a right to work state, but changing from student athletes to
Stech 09/14/23 09:29 PM ET
Most fan bases will dry up .
MrFantastic! 09/15/23 02:56 AM ET
Agree. People love their college football, but in the grand scheme the
JohnsonCItyHokie 09/18/23 01:24 AM ET
Virginia allows local government unions but not state employee unions
mrcaniac 09/15/23 12:50 AM ET
Isn’t collective bargaining allowed in VA for public sector employees?**
CrystalCoveHokie 09/14/23 01:13 PM ET
Only for local governments
mrcaniac 09/14/23 02:45 PM ET