All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

B
Joined: 02/17/2023
Posts: 4,656
Likes: 2,003
Subscriber

I don't know, I completely disagree with that assessment. I disagree

because of the subjective nature of your opinion. I believe the premise is all wrong. I would go to a 24 team playoff like the FSC in a heartbeat. Not directed at you specifically, but who the hell are you(we) to determine whether or not a team deserves to be in the playoffs? All you are doing with your bias is promoting weak OOC schedules, and keeping the G5 from sending more teams to compete. The more teams that have a chance to go to the dance, the less the P2 has the ability to attract all of the talent. That includes the ACC and B12 as well. If Oregon is in fact the best team this year, then they will win the games, expanded, or not. We both know however, that he "best" team doesn't always win in college athletics. The more kids that participate, the better - television ratings and money be damned.
Posted: 12/29/2024 at 06:40 PM ET
(In response to this post by reestuart)

Thread Replies (14)

Full Thread →
That Miami Iowa State game should have been a playoff game. **
Big12 guy 12/29/24 11:40 AM ET
Defense wins championships, so, no. **
obguthr 12/31/24 08:40 AM ET
I believe that as well, and I'm not saying that either team
Big12 guy 12/31/24 09:29 AM ET
Not really **
VaTechHokiesACC 12/29/24 09:35 PM ET
Neither team deserved to be within 1000 miles of the playoff. **
reestuart 12/29/24 06:17 PM ET
I don't know, I completely disagree with that assessment. I disagree
Big12 guy 12/29/24 06:40 PM ET
All "opinions" are subjective, including yours
Pylons 12/29/24 08:21 PM ET
It's a "feeling", I am guilty as charged - but that doesn't
Big12 guy 12/29/24 09:07 PM ET
Neither team did the work to make the playoff. Miami was given two games by
reestuart 12/29/24 07:40 PM ET
Why? Both teams are mediocre.
Maroon Baboon 12/29/24 03:49 PM ET
Based on your line of thinking, we should just proclaim Oregon as the
Big12 guy 12/29/24 03:57 PM ET
Uh. No. ISU and Miami aren't at the same level as Ohio State, Texas, et. al
Maroon Baboon 12/29/24 04:18 PM ET
Again. You made your decision based on perception. **
Big12 guy 12/29/24 04:46 PM ET
I had Kent State in the field.
Maroon Baboon 12/29/24 06:37 PM ET
That is my point. If Oregon blows out everyone, then the polls
Big12 guy 12/29/24 06:53 PM ET