Generally agree. The only sensible solution is . . .
. . . two or maybe three conferences whose strength lies somewhere between P2 status and what we now think of as G5 status.
Once P2 membership stabilizes - whether in the next year or two or several years from now - I think there will remain a group of 30-plus schools that won't make the P2 cut but will be a clear cut above most of the current G5. We can recognize that the Hokies might fit this description but, to avoid emotional arguments, let's set our team aside.
However P2 shakes out, there will be some legitimate football programs left out. In the west these will probably include most if not all of Utah, California, Washington State, Oregon State, Colorado, Arizona and BYU (and others).
In mid-America, the leftovers will probably include most if not all of Texas Tech, TCU, Oklahoma State, Kansas State, Iowa State, Houston, Louisville and Cincinnati (and others).
In the east, the leftovers will probably include most if not all of West Virginia, Pitt, Georgia Tech, UCF, South Florida, Syracuse, Duke, Wake Forest (and others). I posit that if the Hokies get left out, so will NC State or UVa, if not both.
One might assume that some of the schools that consider themselves to be academically elite (Cal, Stanford, Duke et al) might choose to recognize their place in the world and do their own thing in their own way, maybe with the service academies and schools like Tulane or Rice lumped in, and the hope that Vandy and Northwestern may someday follow.
But there will still be a good core of the rest that, when supplemented by schools like San Diego State or Colorado State out west, Memphis and SMU in the midwest and schools like ECU or UAB in the east, it should be rather easy to come up with two groups of 12-16 or, more likely, three groups of 8-12 clustered on a regional basis. And it's all the better if these leagues affiliate in the same fashion that I expect the Big Ten and SEC will eventually do.
So, if you woke up tomorrow and you found out that your Hokie football schedule looked something like this, I'm not sure there would be a ton of complaints.
Wk 1 - Arizona (Non-division)
Wk 2 - JMU (non-conference "buy" game)
Wk 3 - at Houston (Non-division)
Wk 4 - South Florida
Wk 5 - at WVU
Wk 6 - Syracuse
Wk 7 - at Georgia Tech
Wk 8 - Pitt
Wk 9 - at ECU
Wk 10 - UCF
Wk 11 - NC State
Wk 12 - at UVa (non-conference P2)
Thread Replies (20)
After y’all finish throwing up over this post let me know how you feel.
-- cricket77
Jun 07, 2024 at 10:12 AM ET
cricket77
•
06/07/24 10:12 AM ET
i would "detach"**
-- MrBayAreaHokie
Jun 07, 2024 at 07:22 PM ET
MrBayAreaHokie
•
06/07/24 07:22 PM ET
BOTH Dumb and dumber!! And you know what folks say about opinions!!
-- ancient alien 2018
Jun 07, 2024 at 05:17 PM ET
ancient alien 2018
•
06/07/24 05:17 PM ET
Cricket you are heading in the right direction **
-- VPI 1924
Jun 07, 2024 at 01:41 PM ET
VPI 1924
•
06/07/24 01:41 PM ET
I think NCST has a better shot of getting P2 than VT. Hope I am wrong.**
-- 133193Hokie
Jun 07, 2024 at 02:45 PM ET
133193Hokie
•
06/07/24 02:45 PM ET
About the same in my opinion
-- HokiesACC2004
Jun 08, 2024 at 03:10 AM ET
HokiesACC2004
•
06/08/24 03:10 AM ET
I would not be fine with that line up
-- Hokie12thman
Jun 07, 2024 at 01:29 PM ET
Hokie12thman
•
06/07/24 01:29 PM ET
Or VT could just drop football entirely, might be preferable.**
-- HokieNoVA
Jun 07, 2024 at 01:13 PM ET
HokieNoVA
•
06/07/24 01:13 PM ET
So in other words... FBSaa... same as when D1 split into D1 and D1aa**
-- Vienna_Hokie
Jun 07, 2024 at 12:58 PM ET
Vienna_Hokie
•
06/07/24 12:58 PM ET
I do not feel like it will be anything like that.
-- VTCALS72
Jun 07, 2024 at 12:25 PM ET
VTCALS72
•
06/07/24 12:25 PM ET
Generally agree. The only sensible solution is . . .
◄
-- Tailgate Guru
Jun 07, 2024 at 01:20 PM ET
Tailgate Guru
•
06/07/24 01:20 PM ET
That post just about ruined my Friday**
-- CobbCountyHokie
Jun 07, 2024 at 11:50 AM ET
CobbCountyHokie
•
06/07/24 11:50 AM ET
Don’t laugh. Idaho State has a dome**
-- VPI 1924
Jun 07, 2024 at 01:47 PM ET
VPI 1924
•
06/07/24 01:47 PM ET
Idaho has a dome too and I think it is slightly bigger.**
-- VTHokie2000
Jun 07, 2024 at 01:53 PM ET
VTHokie2000
•
06/07/24 01:53 PM ET
I'm way past throwing up from that...
-- Culpeper Hokie
Jun 07, 2024 at 10:58 AM ET
Culpeper Hokie
•
06/07/24 10:58 AM ET