All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

Maroon Baboon
Joined: 10/14/2003
Posts: 30,199
Likes: 22,204

The college calendar, human development, and the nature of athletics and

academics have changed dramatically. It is hard to fit a high school student athlete into the four-year box of an undergraduate degree/eligibility anymore. Just some random, scattered thoughts. Lew Alcindor couldn't play varsity his freshmen year. LeBron James was good enough to play D1 basketball when he was a sophomore in high school. Maybe earlier. Kids can finish their high school requirements earlier these days. A 4-year college degree isn't respected or valued as it once was. The disconnect between academics and athletics is as large as ever. But the gap has always been there, from Eric Dickerson's Trans-Am to Scam Newton's bag man. Most Big time players value payment over a scholarship. Many high school athletes (and their parents, clubs, and high school teams) have put in much more money and time into the honing of skills needed to succeed at the college level. NIL money can keep someone playing longer (and staying in college). I don't see this as a bad thing. Programs and their fan bases want to WIN. For those following football and basketball at the highest level, this is a reality. I mentioned below that I think there should be no age (or year) limits as long as a player is enrolled full time and pursuing a degree. ** Edited by Maroon Baboon at 4/17/2025, 12:10:29 PM
Posted: 04/17/2025 at 12:09 PM ET
(In response to this post by Stech)

Thread Replies (26)

Full Thread →
Could this be th end of the eligibility limits for student athletes, ESPN🔗
Stech 04/16/25 12:40 PM ET
If this isn't, something else will be. It's just a matter of time.
Baltimore_Hokie 04/18/25 10:03 AM ET
The college calendar, human development, and the nature of athletics and
Maroon Baboon 04/17/25 12:09 PM ET
Why not just make eligibility based on number of games played?
HokieAl 04/17/25 08:19 AM ET
Basically it’s full on minor league from here on out
I85Hokie 04/17/25 07:31 AM ET
They need some limits on college sports, how about thinking of HS kids
Stech 04/17/25 08:36 AM ET
The HS kids can play at a D2 or D3 school for 6 or 7 years
tarheelblue 04/17/25 10:32 PM ET
If colleges cared about HS kids, they wouldn't play games on Friday nights
Maroon Baboon 04/17/25 12:27 PM ET
NCAA has been rendered powerless by the courts
mrcaniac 04/17/25 07:34 PM ET
The NCAA will be neutered. The College Basketball Crown will
Big12 guy 04/17/25 07:43 PM ET
Thought about this
The_VT_Rock 04/17/25 08:14 AM ET
To a fault, fans (alums) as so attached to their school and its name that
Maroon Baboon 04/17/25 12:36 PM ET
Seems like people are hellbent on ruining college athletics
SMU Pony 04/16/25 10:18 PM ET
Exactly, let kids coming out HS have a chance, there are bad consequences
Stech 04/17/25 08:33 AM ET
Why should there be any eligibility limits at all?**
CrystalCoveHokie 04/16/25 05:47 PM ET
Nope.
EDGEMAN 04/17/25 07:43 AM ET
Let some people out of High School have a chance like they got out of HS?
Stech 04/16/25 07:50 PM ET
Perhaps any person who is a full time student making progress toward a
Maroon Baboon 04/16/25 06:23 PM ET
You could then call them a student athlete. I like it. **
Big12 guy 04/16/25 08:55 PM ET
It's one of the reasons that I think
Big12 guy 04/16/25 02:23 PM ET
Isn’t there a current proposal or discussion on 5 years to play
VintonHokies 04/16/25 02:41 PM ET
I've thought it should be 5 to play 5 for a while. No redshirts.
reestuart 04/16/25 05:51 PM ET
I would go for that, but there needs to be limit so kids in HS get a chance**
Stech 04/16/25 07:53 PM ET
Officially it is four, with exceptions like red shirting. Most kids I
Big12 guy 04/16/25 02:48 PM ET
Dang it. You made me research it..enclosed **
VintonHokies 04/16/25 03:48 PM ET
FWIW the bylaw is worded to say something along the lines that a student-
VTHokie2000 04/16/25 02:58 PM ET
Thanks for the clarification. **
Big12 guy 04/16/25 03:01 PM ET