All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

AirborneHokie96
Joined: 10/08/1999
Posts: 18,210
Likes: 40,600
Founder Subscriber

Unless Congress steps in, that likelihood is extremely low

and even then, it's not guaranteed. A salary cap is per se illegal under antitrust law unless: -athletes are legally recognized as employees AND -athletes unionize AND -the union agrees to a collectively bargained cap Without all three, a salary cap is just horizontal collusion—the exact thing the NCAA keeps losing in court. Also, schools fear employee status because it triggers: workers’ comp unemployment insurance payroll taxes FLSA wage/hour rules Title IX compensation parity - HUGE liability for workplace injuries - HUGE bargaining obligations grievance procedures arbitration wrongful termination claims - HUGE Schools want cost control, not employment law. Employee status gives them one and saddles them with the other. Also, the NFL/NBA model only works because the entire league bargains as one unit. College sports are structurally incapable of that. Even if athletes unionize, the bargaining unit would likely be: football-only, or school-by-school, or conference-by-conference If bargaining becomes fragmented, salary caps become inconsistent, unenforceable, legally vulnerable and strategically pointless.
Posted: 01/19/2026 at 04:31 PM ET
(In response to this post by VTDC)

Thread Replies (23)

Full Thread →
Darian Mensah QB from Duke to Miami, the price of poker just went up
V333T 01/16/26 05:22 PM ET
💥Just stop it💥**
astrohokie 01/16/26 07:53 PM ET
Here’s a take by the New York Times on the Duke qb transfer**
RJHokie 01/16/26 07:05 PM ET
What a break
crazylane 01/16/26 06:19 PM ET
He can’t count.
VPI 1924 01/17/26 01:53 PM ET
There needs to be a salary cap to try and control the madness **
solareye 01/16/26 06:07 PM ET
Are there salary caps for Coaches/Admin?**
AirborneHokie96 01/17/26 09:00 PM ET
Do you want a cap on just the players or coaches, too? **
Hoakie82 01/17/26 02:00 PM ET
Players only.**
solareye 01/17/26 08:43 PM ET
Fortunately, that will never happen**
AirborneHokie96 01/17/26 09:00 PM ET
Yes it will. There won’t be a long time where college players make more
VTDC 01/18/26 07:33 PM ET
Legally, it will not happen. **
AirborneHokie96 01/19/26 10:04 AM ET
Yes, not in the current structure. But when they are deemed employees and
VTDC 01/19/26 03:01 PM ET
Unless Congress steps in, that likelihood is extremely low
AirborneHokie96 01/19/26 04:31 PM ET
Yes, exactly. A professional organization of the largest 60 football
VTDC 01/19/26 08:05 PM ET
Even though I don’t like duke I feel bad for them
CvilleHokie04 01/16/26 05:38 PM ET
So it turned out to be a 1 yr., 8 million deal**
GCHokieof91 01/16/26 07:43 PM ET
If he transfers, Miami would probably have to pay Duke at least 4 million
CvilleHokie04 01/16/26 07:52 PM ET
If they plenty of time to sign a top shelf QB1 they might be tempted to ...
Atlee Hokie 01/16/26 09:37 PM ET
I hope Duke does sue. The case would be
GCHokieof91 01/16/26 08:12 PM ET
Duke owns the NIL contract though.
RJHokie 01/16/26 05:47 PM ET
Always good when scUM gets screwed. Go IU.**
Atlee Hokie 01/16/26 09:29 PM ET
I've said it many times, you can't spell scUM without UM.
ancient alien 2018 01/16/26 08:05 PM ET
hey Duke is Private and very good legal team, Hope they pursuit it
1947Sunbowl 01/16/26 07:03 PM ET