because the schools decided they would rather have a subjective system instead of an objective one. A subjective system opens the door to corruption potentially creeping into the process. I don't think it is just the P2, because I believe all conferences play a role in helping to make this bed. If you look at the selection process for DI-FBS, DI-FCS, DII, and DIII Playoffs, then you will see that the DI-FCS may be the most objective playoff. It is the only playoff that gives an automatic bid to all conferences interested in participating in the playoffs. The schools have made their bed and now they can lay in it. Some schools will always benefit from it and other schools will be more likely to get screwed in the process for one reason or another. The same is true for the conferences. IIWII at this point in time.