All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

shalpin
Joined: 10/28/2025
Posts: 6
Likes: 4

Top 3 at least.

Big if, obviously, but given the remaining games it would be foolish to argue against at least top 3 if he managed to pull it off. I like him a lot more than I thought I would. I understand the urge to burn everything to the ground, but I also respect how he has handled things thus far and his raw emotion (happiness, tears of joy, pride in his players emotion.. not sideline grumpy man Brian Kelly anger emotion) is something that I seriously value. Monty is still trying, and he's motivating his players to try, even though most people have entirely given up on the season.. That's been lacking with previous coaches, and there's no guarantee that it will continue with future coaches (unless we got a Saban type, I guess.. lol). What needs to change the most IMO (and I know I am not alone here) is the structure and mindset of the athletic department and football operations in general. That seems to be happening, at least with what's being said publicly. Ballein can kick rocks. All of the "good ol' boy" club needs to go. Monty isn't that.
Posted: 10/28/2025 at 01:04 PM ET
(In response to this post by HokieAl)

Thread Replies (36)

Full Thread →
If VT won out to go 7-5 (6-2), where would PM be on your coach list?
HokieAl 10/28/25 12:36 PM ET
I hope he gets a HC or OC job somewhere
HokiesACC2004 10/29/25 05:41 AM ET
Coach of the Year....but "un-possible".**
hok1eboy 10/28/25 10:08 PM ET
I think that if they keep scoring points like they did in the second half,
Stech 10/28/25 06:56 PM ET
He would be the best coach VT didn’t hire.**
NoHuddle 10/28/25 05:21 PM ET
He would get a legit interview and be on my short list.**
Maroon Baboon 10/28/25 04:10 PM ET
People have done the "interim was successful, lets hire him" before
6thStreetHokie 10/28/25 04:08 PM ET
I think Dabo, Brent Key and WFU coach Dickert are ones. Marcus Freeman is
JACHokies 10/28/25 05:04 PM ET
Brent Key disliked this.**
shalpin 10/28/25 04:17 PM ET
He would be adjacent to it**
Beerman 10/28/25 03:31 PM ET
Right now we’re going to be lucky to win 4. FSU is 50/50 shot
Hokiefied 10/28/25 02:32 PM ET
From what I saw Saturday, UVA is a 50/50 game **
HokiesACC2004 10/29/25 05:42 AM ET
I would say…
3Manysons 10/28/25 09:06 PM ET
I agree, a month ago I would give us zero chance against UVA **
HokiesACC2004 10/29/25 05:42 AM ET
yes**
bigbadbird 10/28/25 02:29 PM ET
Won't happen, but would consider if coachNew hasn't been locked-in...
VT757to276 10/28/25 02:23 PM ET
If he pulls that off someone else in P4 just might offer him if we don't.
TekkNerd 10/28/25 02:09 PM ET
🍿🍿🍿🍿**
TomTurkey 10/28/25 01:30 PM ET
Not in the top 5. There is more to running a program than on field. Needs
vivitron73 10/28/25 01:16 PM ET
You know he was a previous, at least somewhat successful HC right?
JoesterVT 10/28/25 02:23 PM ET
You consider 43-53 successful?**
vivitron73 10/28/25 02:26 PM ET
At Tulsa, the smallest FBS school...it's pretty normal
HokieAl 10/28/25 02:47 PM ET
At a school half the size of Wake Forest? He had some success**
Tuckahokie 10/28/25 02:39 PM ET
Ok now look at James Franklins, Bob Chesney's, Shane Beamers, Dan Mullen's
vivitron73 10/28/25 02:44 PM ET
I think, at least for stretches the people in Tulsa did**
JoesterVT 10/28/25 02:28 PM ET
So no**
vivitron73 10/28/25 02:29 PM ET
you mentioned "prove himself" and "2-4 years somewhere with a team..."
JoesterVT 10/28/25 02:33 PM ET
Yes, he needs to prove himself on the recruiting trail and show that he can
vivitron73 10/28/25 02:35 PM ET
Need to complete that scenario
Route460 10/28/25 01:10 PM ET
Top 3 at least.
shalpin 10/28/25 01:04 PM ET
He wouldn't be on my coach list.**
BG Hokie 10/28/25 12:53 PM ET
On mine if he performed as described **
dtcummi 10/28/25 01:36 PM ET
If he gets the mess he took over to a Bowl...hire him**
Tuckahokie 10/28/25 12:40 PM ET
He definitely got the locker room back
Marooned 10/28/25 01:14 PM ET
The team IIWII so if he can squeeze some success, why not let him build it.**
TomTurkey 10/28/25 02:38 PM ET
If anything he's secured a job somewhere
Happy Dog 10/28/25 01:19 PM ET
that's a BIG IF**
Windows NT 10/28/25 12:37 PM ET