All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

P
Joined: 01/05/2001
Posts: 3,103
Likes: 1,289

No, people forget

At the start of the year everyone thought Caleb was positioned perfectly with the Bears with all the talent at the skill positions and strong defense, to win right away. Washington, on the other hand had tons of holes everywhere coming off a 4-13 season Not to mention being an utter failure for the better part of 30 years. Everyone expected a long rebuild. Give credit to Quinn but he was like the commies 3rd or 4th choice. Kingsbury is doing a good job but he went from being fired from the cardinals to some sort of savant. Sort of like Bill Walsh becoming an offensive genius AFTER he drafted Montana. The reality is Jayden is making everybody around him better which is the true mark of a great player. Caleb is talented but made a lot of rookie mistakes and in my opinion he would have struggled his first year no matter where he went.
Posted: 01/13/2025 at 11:14 PM ET
(In response to this post by TheNuke)

Thread Replies (17)

Full Thread →
Q...would Caleb Williams have had this same success in Washington?
TheNuke 01/12/25 11:27 PM ET
No, people forget
Planner_Hokie 01/13/25 11:14 PM ET
A QB landing in a good spot
crazylane 01/13/25 12:24 PM ET
I don't know the answer but Chicago had a much tougher schedule
TheNuke 01/13/25 10:58 AM ET
Idc for either team but Daniels seems more about team than Williams
3TechFanz 01/13/25 10:51 AM ET
I think he'd have been good, but Daniels seems way more polished.**
reestuart 01/13/25 10:04 AM ET
Williams would have had more success in DC relative to himself in Chicago
BG Hokie 01/13/25 08:40 AM ET
I don't think so. Daniel's is just special
HokieR 01/13/25 07:53 AM ET
Daniels has every positive intangible you can have**
Happy Dog 01/13/25 08:45 AM ET
Seriously doubt it. Caleb is a good player on a terrible team in Chicago
Zanderhokie 01/13/25 12:24 AM ET
Magician is a good descriptor...
EDGEMAN 01/13/25 08:11 AM ET
Incredible maturity, work ethic, and football IQ
Happy Dog 01/13/25 06:10 AM ET
No, there has never been a greater lock for ROY. He has arguments for MVP
ChrisLords 01/13/25 03:22 AM ET
there was a big difference in playing maturity
1947Sunbowl 01/12/25 11:59 PM ET
I thought Daniels was more pro ready
VaTechHokiesACC 01/12/25 11:52 PM ET
I thought the Skins should've traded the 1st round pick for a slew of other
ChrisLords 01/13/25 03:19 AM ET
Somehow I don't think Chicago would have been better with Daniels though**
TheNuke 01/13/25 12:13 AM ET
The Bears front office is dumber than a tree stump.
NoHuddle 01/13/25 10:42 AM ET