All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

J
jfrance41 OP
Nov 22, 2024 at 02:48 PM ET
On NIL. Just blindly spending money doesn't guarantee wins. Kansas State
foolishly gave Coleman Hawkins $2 million and he's giving below average production for them, and they lost to a mediocre LSU team. David N'Guessan has been their most valuable player and he's probably making 1/6th of what Hawkins is. I think the best way for both VT football and basketball to succeed in this new era is to have an NIL analytics "front office" to aid coaching staffs in allocating money/targeting players. For starters, not wasting NIL on bringing back 4 wide receivers when you are a run first team, have some talented underclassmen in the WR room, and have major holes at OL/LB/S. For basketball it's a little bit different because they've already had to do that out of necessity but it's hard to run an efficient system in year 1 when you're bringing in 5-6 new rotation pieces every season. I've comped this VT team to Notre Dame last year, who had a bunch of new players and struggled early (lost to Western Carolina and Citadel). They got better as year went on and brought everyone back, and look like a potential bubble team already. The issue is it's a lot easier to keep players at a storied school like ND than it is here. Even if we get NIL to a middle of the ACC level is that enough from keeping bigger schools from poaching our players if they show promise? I'm skeptical of that.

6 Replies

G
GBOHokie
As I watch Tyler Nickel fill it up. I can’t help but wonder about MYs
Ability to gain NIL. Yes I understand he is not in direct control. But he can obviously lobby for more NIL. When I look at Pry and MY they are very different. MY is a tactician. Public speaking/sales doesn’t seem to be his strong suit. I remember a year when my performance was dinged because we didn’t do what we said because we weren’t allocated funds. My boss said I can change your review but tell me. What did you do to try and get money? How many senior executives did you present a case too? What case did you present? Did you do any grassroots lobbying? I don’t know what he can or cannot do. But can he approach the NIL groups and ask for help? Can he present his case? Based on what I see, coaches can ask for people to contribute to NILs. Maybe its happened. But I can’t remember a single appeal from MY asking to contribute a NIL specifically for basketball. Once again. I don’t see that as his strong suit. I realize he has people against him who believe the future is football. Just curious what has he done?
Walkin` Willie Walkin` Willie
We have no basketball specific NIL entity anymore.
Besides, CMY makes plenty of pleas to the big donors but that isn't going to be released for public consumption. A whole lot of assumptions in your post.
W
Woody
NIL analytics "front office" is a brilliant idea
With the cash being thrown around and the repercussions of getting it wrong, this seems like a no brainer.
V
VT ChemE 1986
VT needs a “Moneyball” trained GM
hoosnowahokie hoosnowahokie
He's in Tampa.
J
jfrance41 OP
Cool guy, came to campus when i was there, talked and took Qs from us