All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

Gobbler Guru
Joined: 11/02/1999
Posts: 5,100
Likes: 5,768
Founder

Funding for coaches vs funding for athletes...

is, IMHO, the central point in the whole "what to do about NIL" debate. As college sports have become more professionalized, one of the glaring differences between the franchise-based pro leagues and the college-based pro leagues is the approach to dividing up the revenue pie. Pro players now receive infinitely more of that pie, proportionately, than they did a generation ago. And player salaries for the top pros dwarf coaching salaries. A pro team's spend on roster talent is way higher than its spend on coaching and front office talent. And as pro salaries increase, ticket prices usually follow, but that's about the extent of fan gouging that occurs. Salaries and caps go up because revenue continues to go up. College-based pro sports seems to follow entirely different logic. The structure of the past several decades, where schools, coaches, athletic directors, and assorted hangers-on reap enormous financial rewards, and players received no direct compensation, has now been upended. But the response has not been "now we have to divide the pie differently and share". Nor has it been "how can we grow the pie even faster". It's been "we want to continue to keep most of the money for ourselves, and it's up the fans to help pay the players". Player compensation is not going away. Schools, admins, and coaches are going to have to realize that (a) their own compensation will inevitably have to decline in relative terms and (b) asking fans to be a primary source of funding player salaries is not a sustainable long-term solution.
Posted: 05/06/2026 at 01:53 PM ET
(In response to this post by GCHokie34)

Thread Replies (41)

Full Thread →
A Little NIL Perspective: Building an NCAA Roster in 2026
jjbeat 05/04/26 04:36 PM ET
Quick search says UT MBB program generated $12M in profit, FWIW.**
40ozDistrict 05/05/26 12:21 PM ET
How much NIL dd the fans provide for the team to generate that profit?**
JM397 05/05/26 02:20 PM ET
Help me understand what youre asking...
GCHokie34 05/05/26 03:38 PM ET
Funding for coaches vs funding for athletes...
Gobbler Guru 05/06/26 01:53 PM ET
Agree there is no way to know exactly what "all in" is in terms of $$$.
Vippie1 05/06/26 09:38 AM ET
I mean...there's a way...
GCHokie34 05/06/26 09:48 AM ET
no doubt.
Vippie1 05/06/26 11:28 AM ET
Id like to give you a specific number, but the current admin...
GCHokie34 05/06/26 12:36 PM ET
Another good post. The AthDept follows the United Way
saret 05/06/26 12:54 PM ET
NIL funds can be handled by the university independent of Triumph...
GCHokie34 05/06/26 01:00 PM ET
Thanks for the response. This is an honest question. I believe you
saret 05/06/26 01:10 PM ET
Tennessee/Virginia v. NCAA
GCHokie34 05/06/26 01:44 PM ET
Thanks for the response.**
saret 05/06/26 01:46 PM ET
I was really trying to estimate how much teams spend on players through
JM397 05/06/26 05:05 AM ET
GC, this is an excellent, excellent post. Bravo!**
saret 05/05/26 04:40 PM ET
I thought NIL is an “off books” expense since it is not paid by the school
Femoyer Hokie 05/05/26 03:59 PM ET
July of last year was the start when you could bring NIL in-house
GCHokie34 05/05/26 05:18 PM ET
I believe the University can not touch funds that are NIL
Nelsonia Hokie 05/07/26 12:34 PM ET
Not true**
GCHokie34 05/07/26 04:43 PM ET
That is what the AD stated**
Nelsonia Hokie 05/07/26 06:36 PM ET
There is a lot of context missing here...
GCHokie34 05/07/26 06:44 PM ET
Are we finished adding to our current roster for this season?**
YBYSAIAHokie 05/05/26 12:14 PM ET
No, my bet is they add at least 3 probably 4 more
GCHokie34 05/05/26 05:20 PM ET
From the portal? I thought it was closed.**
YBYSAIAHokie 05/06/26 12:32 PM ET
Likely 2-3 from the portal, 1-2 HS
GCHokie34 05/06/26 12:40 PM ET
Doubt it. IF they can find 2-3 more, another big, a PG and a 3-4 wing.**
ancient alien 2018 05/05/26 02:30 PM ET
5 million?That's like the 10th overall NBA pick. This is insane,competing
HokieBrazil 05/05/26 07:50 AM ET
Ky spent 20 million last year and now the faithful want the HC gone.
ancient alien 2018 05/04/26 06:21 PM ET
That's the thing - if VT spends $5-10MM on a roster and makes the
hokiehill1117 05/05/26 08:34 AM ET
Yeah - no one is asking to match TN in this example….
GoldCoast 05/06/26 09:43 AM ET
Unless youre including rev share, VT did not spend 5-10 mil this season**
GCHokie34 05/05/26 03:41 PM ET
I wouldn't but that's just me.**
ancient alien 2018 05/05/26 10:24 AM ET
I am curious what your target budget would be for VT basketball
hokiehill1117 05/05/26 01:29 PM ET
To be competitive, $8-10 million. 22 wins most seasons. Will it
ancient alien 2018 05/05/26 02:26 PM ET
I think we are on the same page - if we get to spending $8-10MM with
hokiehill1117 05/06/26 08:54 AM ET
Is that 8 to ten include rev share? or just nil**
vtox1 05/05/26 07:09 PM ET
Said in Nate Bargatze's voice, "nobody knows..."**
hokiehill1117 05/06/26 02:49 PM ET
To me it waters down the meaning of it all.
NC Hoke 05/04/26 05:39 PM ET
Waters down the meaning of what? Only difference now is it's in the open.**
marcbvtgm 05/05/26 10:31 AM ET
Salaries
Battlesuggs 05/04/26 05:32 PM ET
Between the NIL and the related "rent a player" for a year model the care
Tuckahokie 05/05/26 06:01 AM ET