I for one was really hoping that the Curse of the Dome and Brent Pry’s legendary single-score struggles would cancel out like competing sine waves. Alas. Well, let’s get ourselves into a better headspace with some happier memories before we get into the Syracuse game.
This article is for TSL Pass subscribers
Get full access to premium articles, recruiting intel, and analysis from the team that's covered Virginia Tech sports since 1996.
Great block. Nothing illegal about it. Out in front and arms aren't grabbing or pulling. Direct push straight into the defenders chest.
GO_HOKIES_GO
These are fun articles that make you think about the process, not just the call. I would say it is not holding (in fact 3 is holding 9 for most of the play. At the end when 3 turns to the ball carrier he is not being prevented from that move by 9 holding him IMO.
HokieGator
I haven't listened to the podcast or seen discussion, but I can see why it was flagged for holding. It happened very quickly but it looks like the defenders upfield shoulder got yanked.
Now, that said, I loathe how holding is called so inconsistently. If that was holding, then there should have probably been about 20 more holding calls in the game.
The block in the back call irritated me more. I think the official just saw the defender go flying by and the blocker with his hands near his back and assumed he was pushed.
RRHokie90
There is a disconnect on what happened at the end of the 1st half.
With 18 seconds to go, VT has 2 (TWO) timeouts. Schlee does his thing and slides down with 12 seconds to go. VT calls a timeout.
The next time we take a snap, there's ~7 seconds to go, we have running clock, and 1 timeout. That can't be....
Either we have 2 timeouts and a running clock OR we have 1 timeout and 17 seconds left with the clock stopped. We ended up with the worse of each option, lost a timeout and had a running clock.
We keep talking like he had to gamble his last timeout and that's not the case. He used one of 2, which should have stopped the clock and put 17 on it. Seems to me the refs confused the issue by forgetting that VT had been charged a timeout.
Ram Hokie
Spot on. After the reversal it was 2nd down and 16 from VTs 45 with 2 TOs. Use TO to stop clock and prevent runoff. Its should have been 17 seconds a TO in the bank to try to get to get into field goal range. Just seemed like a huge cluster at the end of the half when it really wasnt that complicated
RRHokie90
Right...I keep hearing folks post as if we had one timeout and a choice between the 2 outcomes...just not true. The refs screwed us out of a timeout...
TechHokie13
That really confused me also. It sounds like post-game (or halftime, maybe? I don't recall), R told Pry he had 2 TOs, but Pry was looking at the scoreboard which said he only had one. If that's true, that's 100% on Pry, because R can correct the scoreboard. Because, yes, once they took the ball back to where Schlee's knee was down, everything after that - including time outs - is wiped out, for all practical purposes.
On the other hand, R really needs to make sure it's clear how many timeouts a team has. "Coach, there's going to be a 10-second runoff with the clock rolling on my ready. You have two timeouts, do you want to use one to avoid the runoff?" I *really* hope R gave Pry something along those lines; I have no reason to doubt it, but who knows?
bushartbs525
Thanks Tristan for putting my question as the “You make the call” this week. I did watch the game review podcast before reading your article so I ruled this a hold. The point of my question was that I noticed at least 1 SU play before Felton’s hold where the SU WR’s hands were on the outside of both arms of the VT defender. Even though the SU player was able to literally steer the defender out of the play a flag wasn’t thrown. Just be consistent in how the game is called
TechHokie13
That might've happened in the first quarter, and my recording only started with the 2nd. I agree, we strive to be consistent (and a bad rule enforced consistently beats a good rule enforced sporadically, imo), but there's a lot that can go into a holding call. Distance from the runner, timing and magnitude of the restriction, etc. It's hard to say, as there's probably more gray area when it comes to holding than any other foul. That's why I wrote a whole article about it after the 2023 ODU game.
uwhokie
With about 4 minutes left in the game, #1 of Syracuse (Allen) was penalized for unsportsmanlike conduct. Any thoughts on that one? It may be impossible to tell everything that happened on the sideline, but it looked like he just tried to give the ball to the official.
TechHokie13
Yeah, that one looked weird to me. I can't really answer it without wildly speculating (so I'll just do that now, I suppose). My best guess is it has more to do with what he said than anything else.
agray123
I think he spit on a staffer.
uwhokie
Thanks! If that is the case, I found this about the Oregon WR who was kicked out of the Ohio State game.
“Steve Shaw, the NCAA supervisor of officials, said in a text to The Associated Press on Saturday night that any time a player spits on an opponent it is a flagrant unsportsmanlike conduct penalty requiring ejection.”
Lesser offense if you target a staffer?
75hoke
I understand 10 second runoff rule on many different conditions (injured player, penalty, etc) but when the referee calls time to review a play, it just doesn’t seem a 10 second runoff is fair. Why should a team be penalized (particularly if no time outs remained to be used) because of incompetent refs (there, I said it). I could see a scenario where short gain for first down, clock stopped for first down and quick spike of the ball would not use 10 seconds. But a replay for review of spot would result in 10 second runoff.
TechHokie13
It's more to account for the time that almost certainly would have run off if the play was called '"correctly." If Schlee had been whistled down in real time, it absolutely would have taken 10 seconds ir so for Tech to snap the ball. That's what the rule is there for, to prevent the offense from gaining an unfair timeout to get a playcall in during a review.
IV_Hokie12
I wonder if there was miscommunication. I'm pretty sure we took a TO before the review. The game broadcast showed us down that TO. It felt like the refs were asking us to take two TOs to stop the clock watching it live.
TechHokie13
Yeah, that's my biggest gripe with R on this one. He should have been *crystal* clear with Coach about down, distance, status of clock, and timeouts left. It looks like at best, that communication was rather inefficient.
nvpbrown
The "clarifications" here suggesting that taking the run-off was intentional make it look *so* much worse for Pry.
Even if you don't trust your long FG protection, taking a timeout with 0:18 gives you two or three shots at an end zone TD pass for the ACC replay officials to overturn. Or you have two shots at moving the ball 30 yards for a shorter FG. Instead, we eat the runoff and then (barely) get off a running play with a low chance of scoring and a possibly higher chance of coughing up the ball for a Syracuse scoop and score.
It looked a lot better for Pry when I though he might have been screwed by the officials into eating a runoff and basically killing any chances of scoring before the half.
Mark Duncan
I really enjoy Tristan's articles but my goodness, he defends his fellow refs even when it is indefensible.
For example, the phantom block in the back. Shouldn't refs make calls based on what really happened instead of what they think MIGHT have happened?
TechHokie13
Hey now, I said it was a bad call, what more do you want from me? ?
My main point is that I understand how the mistake was made - at game speed it looks very suspicious. But it highlights just how important it is for an official to see contact from start to finish and make the call based on a single indicator.
HokieEngineer
My issue with that one is that the official called what he expected have happen rather than what did happen. They're not supposed to call suspicious plays, they're supposed to call infractions they actually see. (That's why I accept missed holding calls and retaliation unsportsmanlike conduct. It's impossible to see everything it occurs and officials should only call what they actually see.) As you've noted, he was probably attuned to a penalty potentially occurring because of the change in flow. That's a positive in terms of game awareness. But then he called something that wasn't there because he was expecting it to be there. That's a big negative in my book that more than negates the positives of the situational awareness.
footballunsightly
Legal block to me. Going down list of indicators and I don't think Quan checks any off. He's not stationary and his feet are moving with the defender. I say bad call.
22 Comments