All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

M
Joined: 05/08/2019
Posts: 82
Likes: 206

Trending: VT vs NCST

The VT vs NCST rivalry has no doubt raised the level of both programs, and despite NCST winning the last 6 ACC tournaments this rivalry has been very competitive until this year. So what happened? The common sentiment has been that NCST is identifying and developing talent better. And while that IS true, they haven’t been without failure. Those failures may soon be catching up with the Pack. Below is a deep dive into VT vs NCST recruiting the past 5 years. Those hits and misses foretell the results we see today, but a not so subtle shift in tides is occurring, and I predict VT will soon be back on top. In honor of the best sports weekend of the year, here is some reading material for my fellow wrestling junkies out there. Hope you enjoy! 2018 NCST brought in the #6 recruiting class and pretty much nailed it. It was headlined by big boarders T. Hidlay and Camacho, but lower ranked Trombley and Faison proved to be good evals. The VT class was far less impactful. It was small and at the time received HM recognition. Only Dakota Howard remains from that group. 2019 VT reloaded with the #5 class and 3 top 50 prospects in Brady, Andonian and Latona. Also bringing in local product Andy Smith. NCST took a small class which ranked #17 and again was dead on. K. Orine #49 and Trephan #72 both hit. 2020 For VT I would consider this the recruiting class most responsible for the disparity in our programs this season. VT brought in a big class which was ranked #9 overall. Catka #6, Hillegas #51, Ulrey #57, Ventresca #69, and Sam fisher. This class really struggled to hold par with the level of production being recruited by the Wolfpack. This cycle NCST brought in the #8 class consisting of Scott #19, Trumble #43 and Ryan Jack #46. In hindsight these 3 consecutive years fortell the results we are seeing today. NCST was recruiting at a high level and hitting the evals. They also grabbed solid contributors in the lower ranks with Trombley and Trephan. But 2021 was a turning point. In 2021 the Pack uncharacteristically struck out on the #4 ranked recruiting class. Only #46 Fields remains from that group. VT added Flynn and Trey Kibe in a small class. In 2022 both teams reload, NCST with the #3 class and VT #10. Despite NCST nabbing 4 top 50 recruits in Fishback #5, Singleton #10, Arrington #16 and Horne #35, early returns would indicate we have the upper hand with Henson #7 and Stewart #31, along with Crook who was a great eval at #69. 2023 is the year that could really set the tone for the next era of this rivalry. VT with the #7 class seems to have hit it out of the park. Mullen #7, Sasso #26 Church #29 and Hipolito #57 could be high level starters. It will be interesting to see what weight Church fills into. Mason #85 and Frazier HM round out the class. NCST took a small class with Buesgens #20 headlining along with V. Robinson #46. TLDR: If you’ve read up to this point, the takeaway seems clear. NCST isn’t doing anything spectacular in terms of development. Their high level contributors were expected to be just that, and good recruiting and evaluation from 2018, 2019 and 2020 continue to pay dividends for them. Our comparatively down years in 2018 and 2020 couldn’t keep pace, and we see the results now. The years ahead will be a different story. Our 2022 and 2023 classes have set a new tone, and the balance of power could shift in our favor very soon. S/o @Hikinghokie who correctly reminded us earlier in the season that our reinforcements are here, they’re just redshirting.
Posted: 03/17/2024 at 11:56 AM ET

Thread Replies (30)

Full Thread →
Trending: VT vs NCST
Mr McGibblets 03/17/24 11:56 AM ET
State does things with scholarships we can’t do right now
Vidi Vici Veni 03/17/24 06:03 PM ET
Could you elaborate on what that is? **
Julez90VT 03/17/24 11:01 PM ET
Also, if they qualify for Pell get full needs
Vidi Vici Veni 03/18/24 07:26 AM ET
Just qualify for Pell? Or full Pell?
Pylons 03/18/24 06:03 PM ET
In NC, out of state kids are are charged in state rates
Hikinghokie 03/17/24 11:33 PM ET
That may not be completely true
Pylons 03/18/24 05:58 PM ET
Can something change in Virginia to fix that disadvantage? **
Julez90VT 03/18/24 03:47 PM ET
Sure, but it's a state law fix, not a VT fix
Hikinghokie 03/18/24 04:26 PM ET
Do we ever have anyone working on our behalf to fight for these type of
Julez90VT 03/18/24 08:18 PM ET
We consistently have numerous people in government lobbying for us
donjfs3 03/18/24 09:00 PM ET
This was great. thank you.**
tigerpark135 03/17/24 04:48 PM ET
BTW, did Kibe give up wrestling or transfer(where)??**
wasris 03/17/24 04:44 PM ET
He gave up wrestling completely...
TheStateGuy 03/17/24 06:51 PM ET
It doesn't look like we're developing very well
Baltimore Hokie 03/17/24 04:35 PM ET
I wouldn't put too much stock into recruiting rankings
tigerpark135 03/17/24 04:55 PM ET
I feel like wrestling recruiting rankings are some of the best actually
Hikinghokie 03/17/24 05:58 PM ET
So then you don't agree with the OP's methodology?
Baltimore Hokie 03/17/24 04:58 PM ET
Excellent post**
HokieRat 03/17/24 02:13 PM ET
Really great analysis here and spot on IMO.
Hokie Flyer 03/17/24 01:51 PM ET
They develop guys really well
Hikinghokie 03/17/24 01:33 PM ET
Still think Pop's best development work was M Macchiavello
Jeffrey4VT 03/17/24 06:52 PM ET
Insane career trajectory
Hikinghokie 03/17/24 11:37 PM ET
Hard to argue there.**
Nafeikoh 03/17/24 08:32 PM ET
Good post. They still develop guys very well, however we act like they're
donjfs3 03/17/24 12:38 PM ET
Good read. Thanks!**
Pylons 03/17/24 12:12 PM ET
thanks for posting
VTwinsdad 03/17/24 12:09 PM ET
Nice synopsis , but I’ll push back a bit on 2022.
WolfpackPins 03/17/24 04:55 PM ET
We will see
Mr McGibblets 03/17/24 08:09 PM ET
Its gonna get weird at HWT next year
WolfpackPins 03/17/24 08:43 PM ET
If Trumble can handle the weight he should be your guy IMO **
donjfs3 03/17/24 09:54 PM ET