All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

AbsolutVT03
Joined: 01/05/2001
Posts: 36,169
Likes: 25,823
Lifetime

Regarding the “don’t leave it up to the committee” posts. I get it.

I’m not arguing we should or shouldn’t have hosted. I understand the sentiment and don’t disagree with it. But at the same time unless you are a top five team your fate will always be left up to the committee in some way. Obviously we did ourselves no favors by losing to Pitt and Clemson. But we even if we reversed those results we still could have been snubbed. We would have had a more justified argument but that wouldn’t have changed anything. Outside of the elite teams everyone’s resume will always have warts. And a selection committee can pretty much pick and choose which warts to ignore or emphasize. And next year the criteria used to exclude us from hosting might not factor in at all. We see it in college basketball every season. It’s similar to a point I’ve made previously regarding officiating. When a bad call (or calls) play a major factor in a loss people like to say “don’t leave it up to officials” which in theory makes sense. In reality unless you are blowing a team out then you are always vulnerable to a bad call impacting the outcome. Again I get it. Control what you can control. I just think that argument is overly simplistic. Just a a random thought I had on a rainy Monday morning.
Posted: 05/12/2025 at 11:18 AM ET

Thread Replies (18)

Full Thread →
Regarding the “don’t leave it up to the committee” posts. I get it.
AbsolutVT03 05/12/25 11:18 AM ET
I also am not a fan of "let them play" and "officials should not affect..:"
VAHokie89 05/12/25 01:53 PM ET
As far as officiating in general my biggest complaint is almost always with
AbsolutVT03 05/12/25 05:04 PM ET
I just hate it for the young ladies involved
VTChip 05/12/25 01:23 PM ET
How many teams with a .500 conference record and 21 losses, overall, have
VT One 05/12/25 10:46 PM ET
It’s happened before. Let me think which team…oh yeah…Alabama **
hokiepro 05/13/25 07:31 AM ET
But the other issue is that a couple of teams could probably
VAHokie89 05/12/25 01:55 PM ET
Nobody below 16 in RPI with worse than 100 OOC SoS has hosted
hokiepro 05/12/25 02:02 PM ET
Yep. First time EVER committee cites “win percentage vs top 50”
hokiepro 05/12/25 01:45 PM ET
counter point, being in town for graduation would be a huge distraction
VermontDDS 05/12/25 01:37 PM ET
That wasn’t the reason (supposedly) that they weren’t selected**
VTChip 05/12/25 01:39 PM ET
i don't think they could use that excuse
VermontDDS 05/12/25 01:48 PM ET
Exactly. This time they pulled out “win % vs top 50”
hokiepro 05/12/25 02:06 PM ET
We'll just continue to support in every way we can**
TomTurkey 05/12/25 01:33 PM ET
To arms!**
TomTurkey 05/12/25 01:44 PM ET
Probably got a call from the [former] Wake Forest AD **
TomTurkey 05/12/25 01:32 PM ET
Well said. I agree completely.**
WestEndHokie39 05/12/25 01:12 PM ET
We had a saying at work, "[ ], where your best is not good enough!"**
TomTurkey 05/12/25 11:34 AM ET
I agree…
MrFantastic! 05/12/25 11:25 AM ET