Login | Sign Up
TechSideline

All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

Conference Realignment Board
◀ ▶
VTHokie2000
Joined: 01/01/2005
Posts: 41,416
Likes: 17,028
VTHokie2000

You said people objected to Tulane and JMU making the field because they

would rather see Notre Dame and Texas play in the game. I said they would quickly lose interest in the game involving Notre Dame and/or Texas if Notre Dame and/or Texas end up losing that game by 20 or 30+ points. My point is just because a blue blood makes the field, it doesn't automatically mean the game will end up being a better game than a game where the opponent is Tulane or JMU. For example, if Oregon beats JMU 52-0 or 82-0, then people will be saying that Notre Dame or Texas would have given Oregon a "better game." I'm suggesting that may not be a safe assumption to make because I have given examples where a P4 team has laid an egg in a Playoff game. So it is just as possible Oregon could have beaten Notre Dame or Texas by a similar lopsided margin.
Posted: 12/10/2025 at 05:03 PM ET
(In response to this post by Baltimore_Hokie)

Thread Replies (50)

Full Thread →
ND AD’s interviews
RandomAsianGuy • 12/09/25 09:37 PM ET
The rule next year protects them
SpeakToDamien • 12/10/25 09:43 AM ET
The ACC tiebreaker rules are an asinine way to arbitrate a tie.
Baltimore_Hokie • 12/10/25 10:04 AM ET
Yep. I think head-to-head and ranking. Nothing else should matter.**
reestuart • 12/10/25 02:15 PM ET
Well football is king (of the world) and American football wishes it was
VTHokie2000 • 12/10/25 12:19 PM ET
Yeah matching the two highest ranked programs in
mancunian • 12/10/25 11:26 AM ET
The problem with relying on the FBS Playoff Poll is it is highly likely to
VTHokie2000 • 12/10/25 12:47 PM ET
I mean, I get it, the CFP poll is dictated by whatever ESPN wants.
Baltimore_Hokie • 12/10/25 02:39 PM ET
The SEC didn't have its 2 highest ranked teams playing in its CCG.
VTHokie2000 • 12/10/25 02:54 PM ET
You're misunderstanding what I'm saying. I'm talking about a TIE BREAKER.
Baltimore_Hokie • 12/10/25 02:58 PM ET
I believe the ACC did use the BCS Poll at one time as apart of its
VTHokie2000 • 12/10/25 03:11 PM ET
This. If the B12 championship game was not played, or
Big12 guy • 12/10/25 03:24 PM ET
If BYU had won the game, then it would have been interesting to see how far
VTHokie2000 • 12/10/25 03:40 PM ET
The best explanation - TT just had BYU's number, both times they played.
Baltimore_Hokie • 12/10/25 03:30 PM ET
100%**
Big12 guy • 12/10/25 03:35 PM ET
The reason you use the CFP ranking as the tie breaker is simple:
Baltimore_Hokie • 12/10/25 03:21 PM ET
Not if the G conferences get multiple bids and the P2s are ranked 1-6.
VTHokie2000 • 12/10/25 03:32 PM ET
We can 100% agree on the CFP's lack of credibility, and the clear as day-
Baltimore_Hokie • 12/10/25 03:35 PM ET
If the process is going to gain any credibility, then the first step is
VTHokie2000 • 12/10/25 03:47 PM ET
Agree. In fact, they should just stop farting around and do what everyone-
Baltimore_Hokie • 12/10/25 03:56 PM ET
Are you sure that is what ESPN want? I would think ESPN wants only the
VTHokie2000 • 12/10/25 04:05 PM ET
14 at large spots lets them get whoever they want in.
Baltimore_Hokie • 12/10/25 04:23 PM ET
Maybe so, but how quickly will those people lose interest if Notre Dame
VTHokie2000 • 12/10/25 04:29 PM ET
Just for fun, let's imagine a 24 team CFP this year:
Baltimore_Hokie • 12/10/25 05:13 PM ET
ESPN may still prefer to only have P2s or at the very least as many SEC
VTHokie2000 • 12/10/25 05:18 PM ET
ESPN only owns the rights for a period of time. Baltimore's
Big12 guy • 12/10/25 05:35 PM ET
I don't disagree. I'm not sure will give up its grip that easily though**
VTHokie2000 • 12/10/25 05:37 PM ET
Half the SEC is in that field, lol. You can stop playing devils advocate-
Baltimore_Hokie • 12/10/25 05:21 PM ET
I am having fun here. I want the field to be 100% SEC with a certain
VTHokie2000 • 12/10/25 05:36 PM ET
I think you meant a G5 conference champ lose by 20 or 30 in first round.
Baltimore_Hokie • 12/10/25 04:39 PM ET
No, I meant blue bloods and other P2 teams
VTHokie2000 • 12/10/25 04:51 PM ET
If a blue blood loses by 20 or 30 to anyone, I'm not sure what to say.
Baltimore_Hokie • 12/10/25 04:52 PM ET
You said people objected to Tulane and JMU making the field because they ◄
VTHokie2000 • 12/10/25 05:03 PM ET
I guess? My point is that if you let the 10 conference champs in, and have-
Baltimore_Hokie • 12/10/25 05:15 PM ET
The number of at-large teams is immaterial to me because the only purpose
VTHokie2000 • 12/10/25 05:25 PM ET
it's not likely, but with money and the transfer portal, it
Big12 guy • 12/10/25 04:47 PM ET
You might have better luck getting Ohio State to play in the Rubber Bowl,
VTHokie2000 • 12/10/25 05:15 PM ET
They did, so Toledo had a home game
Big12 guy • 12/10/25 05:20 PM ET
It was, but it wasn't to a degree. I get that Toledo made more money in
VTHokie2000 • 12/10/25 05:30 PM ET
The only way Toledo will get OSU to play at the Glass
Big12 guy • 12/10/25 05:37 PM ET
I agree, but since Baltimore wants us to "have fun," that is my version of
VTHokie2000 • 12/10/25 05:39 PM ET
Game Day on a Tuesday!**
Big12 guy • 12/10/25 05:41 PM ET
MACxactly**
VTHokie2000 • 12/10/25 06:35 PM ET
It's a no brainer from where I'm sitting. I'm in. **
Big12 guy • 12/10/25 04:04 PM ET
it's always been that way. The blue bloods will always get theirs. **
Big12 guy • 12/10/25 12:59 PM ET
I have a Pete Bavacqua on line one sir, he would like to discuss this post.**
Baltimore_Hokie • 12/10/25 02:40 PM ET
I don't disagree, but my point is that conferences historically have
VTHokie2000 • 12/10/25 01:42 PM ET
My bet is that the ACC will change the tie breaking rules. **
Big12 guy • 12/10/25 02:03 PM ET
They 100% will. Before Pete B. said, "hold my beer,"
Baltimore_Hokie • 12/10/25 02:42 PM ET
Because of the tie breaking rules, I read that if ND
Big12 guy • 12/10/25 09:54 AM ET
Let them play 8 games first. **
RandomAsianGuy • 12/10/25 01:22 PM ET