All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

S
Joined: 07/30/2012
Posts: 13,519
Likes: 11,466

MJ Collins played 50 minutes against BC this year and scored zero points

So what you’re saying is all the games that were close losses in which Collins was playing 20+ minutes we would’ve lost anyway with Alleynes better defense and 5+ points per game over what Collins scores? I love MJC’s hustle and moxy, his defense is OK too. There is no question about who’s a better player between him and Alleyne though. In fact Alleyne would’ve gotten his starting spot back after 10 games when Maddox was invisible and we could’ve redshirted Collins
Posted: 02/27/2023 at 01:59 PM ET
(In response to this post by Hokeedokee)

Thread Replies (30)

Full Thread →
Now that the season is over, can we agree Alleyne was a massive loss?
soflahokie 02/27/23 08:51 AM ET
Yes, with Maddox falling off the map he was a big loss.
4dhokies 02/28/23 12:03 PM ET
yes - he was one of our better wing defenders
kingofcassell 02/28/23 11:19 AM ET
Big loss, Mike would have sat MJ and played N Alleyne
tallahasseehokie 02/27/23 05:24 PM ET
I agree that you are negative 99% of the time. The season is not over.**
Walkin` Willie 02/27/23 02:18 PM ET
No, we traded a good offensive guy who was a really difficult matchup
King of Hokies 02/27/23 02:10 PM ET
I mean it’s not OVER over but it’s basically over.
hokiepro 02/27/23 01:05 PM ET
no**
Big D 02/27/23 12:36 PM ET
No. Methinks you're suffering from a severe case of Premature Evaluation.
YBYSAIAHokie 02/27/23 12:35 PM ET
Disagree. Storm was a bigger loss.
Hokiepopt 02/27/23 11:14 AM ET
Storm didn’t have any years left I don’t believe **
hokiepro 02/27/23 12:53 PM ET
I'd argue that the loss of Chester Frazier may have been the real culprit
The_Phew 02/27/23 11:09 AM ET
You've got it right - certainly Alleyne would have played better defense at
IronBlood 02/27/23 03:17 PM ET
Frazier
Midwestguy 02/27/23 01:51 PM ET
Oh, I don't blame him for leaving.
The_Phew 02/27/23 01:55 PM ET
Huh? Cattoor never played at Wofford
HokieAl 02/27/23 01:07 PM ET
You're right re:Cattoor, but Frazier's bio at VT mostly bragged about:
The_Phew 02/27/23 01:13 PM ET
Loss - maybe. Massive loss - no way.**
GCHokieof91 02/27/23 11:05 AM ET
Defense
Midwestguy 02/27/23 02:08 PM ET
Sorry GCHokie34, I replied to wrong post. **
Midwestguy 02/27/23 02:13 PM ET
You replied to the wrong person to boot -- we have multiple "GC" Hokies...
nvpbrown 02/28/23 12:20 AM ET
Sorry**
Midwestguy 02/28/23 08:16 AM ET
I agree wholeheartedly.
SkoHokies 02/27/23 10:59 AM ET
Agree? No.**
Brown Water 02/27/23 10:19 AM ET
We can't.**
Pylons 02/27/23 10:16 AM ET
Personally don't think we would have won a single game with him that we
Hokeedokee 02/27/23 10:11 AM ET
MJ Collins played 50 minutes against BC this year and scored zero points
soflahokie 02/27/23 01:59 PM ET
I am not talking about MJ...What he is contributing - good and bad - is
Hokeedokee 02/27/23 03:24 PM ET
He was ONLY because we lost Rice and Maddox for much of ACC play
hokiepro 02/27/23 09:49 AM ET
Why do posters base opinion on partial biased facts?
TomTurkey 02/27/23 10:01 AM ET
He was a small loss, probably not massive
GretnaHokie 02/27/23 09:22 AM ET