All Hokie, All the Time. Period. Presented by First Bank & Trust Company

David Cunningham
Joined: 07/02/2021
Posts: 8,013
Likes: 25,011
Lifetime

The point I was trying to make was not that the criticism is unreasonable.

It is reasonable. It's reasonable to criticize Young. It's reasonable to criticize the players, too. Everyone plays a role in this. You don't lose multiple games at the buzzer without multiple people being at fault. Young needs to coach better, especially in the final minutes, and I'm sure he understands that. The players need to execute better, especially in the final minutes, and I'm sure they understand that. Do that and you are probably in the NCAA Tournament. We wouldn't be sitting here having a bubble discussion. It comes down to simple stuff — forcing a miss on Wake Forest and Stanford's final possessions, making free throws and not turning the ball over against SMU, not fouling and sending Miami to the free throw line, etc. Those are things the Hokies could control but did not, and the other team beat them. That's on everybody. The point I was trying to make, though, is this: Regardless of who you want to blame for how this season is going, the overall situation of Virginia Tech men's basketball won't change, even if there is a head coaching change. Hypothetically, say Mike Young retires and the Hokies have to go hire a new head coach. It'll likely be a high-profile assistant coach or a mid-major head coach who is looking for a step up. They will be dealing with a nearly identical pool of resources to Young. (Maybe slightly better if there's some new coach shot in the arm in terms of donations.) Those resources are towards the bottom of the ACC. Now, you can still win. It is possible. You have to construct the right roster, coach the players the right way, go out and schedule the right games, then go out and win the right games, which means executing at a high level against other really good teams. It's certainly not impossible. It's more difficult to do when you're a lower-funded team compared to the other teams you're playing, though. For example, the Tampa Bay Rays can make a World Series here and there when the chips fall their way, and they can be a playoff contender most seasons. They can be good despite the odds being against them, but it's not as guaranteed as a team like the Yankees and Red Sox, who have more resources. You can have success, but it won't be as easy, and you might have to think outside of the box to do so. The margin for error is slim for everyone, but even more so for a team like the Hokies with the resources they have. But back to blowing leads. Imagine if Amani Hansberry doesn't lose the ball out of bounds with 4:54 remaining at Miami. Imagine if Tobi Lawal doesn't foul Tre Donaldson and send him to the foul line with 12.5 seconds left. They're controllable things. Lawal missed a foul shot yesterday with 1:33 left. Jailen Bedford missed an open three. I think that's what makes it more frustrating than anything. Tech has been in a position to win these kind of games but has tripped itself up time and time again. It's not just one thing; it's a multitude of things. Fouling in bad spots, not defending well enough, missing free throws, missing shots, not taking care of the ball, not managing the clock. That's on everybody — Young, the coaching staff, the players. They all know that, and the criticism is completely reasonable, as stated. The bottom line is VT should've won at Wake Forest, vs. Stanford, at SMU and at Miami. They blew those games. And I understand where fans are coming from when they say they want a change at the top. I've seen tweets and message board posts about it everywhere. The goal of the discussion on the podcast was to provide some perspective on the whole situation — not to reduce criticism or give the team a pass. Where does VT stand, and if a change happens, what does the situation look like? That was the point of bringing it up. I hope that makes sense. I'm not trying to keep people from ragging on Young and the team. Tech's played poorly late in games far too many times this year, and criticism is warranted. I think a lot of fans are thinking ahead to a potential change and what it would look like — trust me, that's basically all the comments on my articles and on Twitter have been — and I wanted to go, "Well, for those of you discussing this topic, here's where VT stands in terms of the ACC picture and its resources. Is the grass greener somewhere else? TBD."
Posted: 02/18/2026 at 03:01 PM ET
(In response to this post by sarg003)

Thread Replies (46)

Full Thread →
Completely understand the resources argument the guys are making
sarg003 02/18/26 02:04 PM ET
The point I was trying to make was not that the criticism is unreasonable.
David CunninghamAdmin 02/18/26 03:01 PM ET
My take away from your post is that VT doesn't now, and probably won't ever
ancient alien 2018 02/18/26 09:29 PM ET
The grass greener was essentially a hypothetical,
David CunninghamAdmin 02/18/26 09:40 PM ET
Ahh Gotcha Thanks. BTW, can you guys ever see a time when VT is funded
ancient alien 2018 02/18/26 09:44 PM ET
Well, looking back,
David CunninghamAdmin 02/18/26 09:57 PM ET
For Hoops guys like me, that's just depressing.**
ancient alien 2018 02/18/26 10:00 PM ET
I guess my question is related to the funding. Who says how much MBB gets?
Tombo 02/18/26 07:56 PM ET
Those questions all need to be solidified with FB before we can
VT ChemE 1986 02/18/26 08:36 PM ET
Only if it's the same pot of money...Maybe there's a different pot to be
Tombo 02/18/26 08:50 PM ET
I understand your point, but I don't think funding has anything to do...
MP4VT2004 02/18/26 07:17 PM ET
If you are basing your thoughts on the program based on posts here
Moseley Hokie 02/18/26 07:38 PM ET
Take a different perspective
Moseley Hokie 02/18/26 05:57 PM ET
Amen brother. You fire Mike Young
GCHokieof91 02/18/26 05:22 PM ET
Firing him now would be unwise, with the current financial situation.
ancient alien 2018 02/18/26 09:37 PM ET
Good post, a couple of points though.
NC Hoke 02/18/26 05:13 PM ET
CMY contract
Midwestguy 02/18/26 08:28 PM ET
Please, not Whit of all people.**
lazarus1 02/18/26 09:34 PM ET
Your wrote:
Pride_and_Joy 02/18/26 03:31 PM ET
Agreed. That was a pretty out on the limb statement by DC. **
40ozDistrict 02/18/26 07:16 PM ET
Well, from a W-L perspective, sure.
David CunninghamAdmin 02/18/26 04:04 PM ET
Is VT in the bottom 5 of the ACC in men's basketball funding?**
ancient alien 2018 02/18/26 09:40 PM ET
In that realm, yes.
David CunninghamAdmin 02/18/26 09:42 PM ET
Just deplorable. Thank you**
ancient alien 2018 02/18/26 09:46 PM ET
You seem to think "the situation" is something that excludes the coach
Pride_and_Joy 02/18/26 05:39 PM ET
That was not my intent. I'll try to rephrase. Maybe I didn't word it well.
David CunninghamAdmin 02/18/26 09:37 PM ET
Yes, thanks for clarifying. **
Pride_and_Joy 02/18/26 11:32 PM ET
Why can’t the situation
fakehokiestolenvalor 02/18/26 04:56 PM ET
Agreed! The head coach does matter - even if the resources are the same.
huskerHokie 02/18/26 04:01 PM ET
Good post.**
saret 02/18/26 03:27 PM ET
My take
Vippie1 02/18/26 03:27 PM ET
Agreed. It is what it is. There is nothing historically wrong
VT ChemE 1986 02/18/26 03:16 PM ET
Disagree on Lawal. Beyond his injury he has essentially had two hoid games
DCL 02/18/26 05:57 PM ET
I think you are seeing Lawal's skill ceiling. He is a freak athlete
VT ChemE 1986 02/18/26 06:18 PM ET
It is a problem. He's had 3 NCAA level teams in 4 years...
GoldCoast 02/18/26 04:09 PM ET
The problem is that MY's style of play requires peak efficiency to win.
Gobbler Guru 02/18/26 04:23 PM ET
We have the wrong coach then for sure. I'd agree with you on his last 2..
GoldCoast 02/18/26 04:33 PM ET
Yes, I think this team is constructed differently, but...
Gobbler Guru 02/18/26 04:35 PM ET
That is fact. The freedom the team noted early on is non existent once
Hokies23 02/18/26 05:01 PM ET
I think we have forgotten how young this team is.
Jwunderdog 02/18/26 03:41 PM ET
Did you do this podcast before my post this morning?
Jwunderdog 02/18/26 03:16 PM ET
Lol, the podcast was yesterday. I must've missed your
David CunninghamAdmin 02/18/26 04:01 PM ET
Solid points. In the end, cutting through all BS, it boils down to money
Zanderhokie 02/18/26 03:13 PM ET
100 % Correct
Midwestguy 02/18/26 03:30 PM ET
Great Post!.....
2hhoop3 02/18/26 03:07 PM ET
Just have to win the tournament **
bigbadbird 02/18/26 02:49 PM ET
agree!**
lazarus1 02/18/26 02:25 PM ET